69-91 Ordinance
- ,,,-,'~
. .. RECORD OF ORDINANCES
Dayton Legal Blank Co. Form No. 30043
Ordinance NO.m m~.~~~.~. Passed.m__mumm ______uunn mumm__19m..u
AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE LOWEST AND BEST BID
FOR ROAD SALT FOR THE TIME PERIOD COVERING
NOVEMBER 1, 1991 THROUGH MARCH 31, 1992 AND
r'l AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO ENTER INTO A
CONTRACT GOVERNING THE PROCUREMENT OF SAID SALT.
1
\...-'
WHEREAS, after advertising and receiving bids for road salt
for the time period covering November 1, 1991 through March
31, 1992; and,
WHEREAS, Council has determined that the bid submitted by
Morton International, Inc. in the amount of $32.75/ton, is the
lowest and best bid;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the city of
Dublin, state of Ohio, ~ of the elected members
concurring:
Section 1. That the bid submitted by Morton International,
Inc. in the amount of $32.75/ton for road salt for the time
period covering November 1, 1991 through March 31, 1992, is
hereby accepted.
Section 2. That the City Manager is hereby authorized to
enter into a contract with Morton International, Inc. ,
governing the procurement of said salt as specified within
said bidder's bid proposal and the City's bid documents on
file in the Division of Personnel & Purchasing.
Section 3. That this Ordinance shall take effect and be in
force on the earliest date permitted by law.
r' Passed this 'lot. day of ~ 1991-
t ,
~ ~~-/
~r - presidi Officer
Attest:
~~ {/ ~~
Cl k of Counc
Sponsor: Maintenance Superintendent
Director of Personnel & Purchasing
City Manager
I, .
f' . . lerk of Council h b .
oFegomg IS 0 true copy d;, . , " ' ere y certlfy.thal the
duf'" d ,nan.e ResoJut,on No 6 9- 9/
dro ~~ciJ of the City of Dul,rn 0; :--h/~
oy of ' . .",., dlO, on t e____
,-. ~J.,~r I /7',?/
. ~ ---~~-- - -'.--
t...... ~
;
I h~-'... ..... .....,... '.' '~/"
;,' '.' ~: .'. . ,.. ": "r'v " ... ,... ~ ..... t ~. h
. .,,', 0' ....., .,........~.apose;nt~
CIty of " ,.1 ~ 'r (\...~....."F) '..r S",-; .;, :'11 'It: n' ,:" r, . R . de d
~ . .~, . .. "'~""'.II..J..O eVlse Ge.
___..".___.."._______.._~.._.......,._..~,.__,_....__~.._..<__~,.~~,__"~,~~~~.=~~~~M_... .~".".~._~~~~~,----~..~~...---=~~~~.."",.....,..--.-....~,~....".., _1Ilo.o~,'~
~.~ ~.,-'"--""-- ~~ , ] ,
IJ
0
t::'\:I
Q) Q)
oo..c: '\:I4-l 00 .,-l
t:: .IJ I r-l 0 0 .,-l4-lQ)t::'\:I(J)0
l-l t:: ..-I .IJ l-l ::l .IJ .IJ .,-l .IJ 0 r-l tll .IJ
0 0 ~ >-. r-lQ)0t:: Q) r-l.IJCJtll.IJ::l Q)
tn . . r-l ..-I Q) tll.o tll.IJ~O >-.00 tllr-l Q) t::- 0 l-l >-.00
I 00 00 0 .IJ.o CJ 00 r-l .,-l .IJ tll 00 tll p.. l-l U') ~ Q) .IJ tll
a t:: t:: CJ 00 tll I '\:I <000 ..-Il-l oo(IJQ)N ~.,-ll-l
o 0 ao tllCJ.IJ.,-lQ) a \O',-l(IJUO a .IJ .>-.ouo
l-l .,-l o.,-lt:: -,-l0.IJ.,-l 0 .:>..-1 .IJ 0 (IJr-l-<:t l-lr-l .IJ
4-l.IJ l-l.IJ',-lQ)'\:It::t::4-l l-l . N 0 Q) 00 l-l.tll<C""lQ).oQ)(IJ
tll 4-l cd ::l t:: tll .,-l 4-l(IJC""ll-l..c:..c: 4-l(IJ ~:>..c:
U 00 CJ CJ Q) r-l ..-I >-. CJ t::~p..CJ.lJt:: t:: l-l .,-l tll .IJ t::
..... t:: .,-l 00 .,-l .IJ .0 tll ..c: Q) t:: 0 .,-l.,-l 00 0 0 .4-lr-l .,-l
tn 04-l Q) 4-l .,-l I a .IJ p.. o .,-l 4-l Q)..c: >-. Q) .,-l r-l >-. 0 Q) Q) >-.
i .,-l.,-l .IJ .,-l ..c: 4-l .,-l 00 .,-l.IJO'\:l~.o.IJ .IJ .IJ 0 .IJ '\:I'\:I.o.IJ
.IJ CJ tllCJ~O'\:l.IJ~ .IJ tll ::l r-l . tll tll CJ .,-l Q) ::l r-l .
tll Q) .,-l Q) Q) r-l 00 tllCJ'\:Ir-ll-l'\:ltll>-. ..-I CJ U CJ p..r-l'\:l tll >-.
.,-l p.. :> p..(IJ'\:I',-l tll'\:l tll .,-l .,-l.,-l CJ Q) Q) (J) .IJ :>.,-It:: ',-laCJQ)(IJ.IJ
:>00 Q) 00 .,-l tll 4-l 00 Q) I :>4-l.ot::~l-l ..-I Q)4-l.,-lQ)l-l::lt::l-l .,-l
Q) '\:I Q) -,-l .IJ .IJ . Q)..-I .,-l o.,-l Q) r-l '\:I .,-l ..c: p.. '\:I .,-l .,-l Q) r-l
'\:I.IJ .IJ .IJ .IJ CJ .IJ tll t:: >-. '\:I CJ Q) r-l::lCJ..-I CJ Q) .IJ ::l CJ .,-l
r-l '\:I r-l r-l 00 Q) tll Q) Q) .IJ Q) .IJ .IJ .0 l:T' tll CJ '\:I Q) ::l '\:Il-l.IJl:T'tllCJ
o tll .,-l tll tll t:: p....c: l-l 00..-1 op..tllo Q) r-l tll ..-I p.. r-l >-..,-l 0 0 Q) r-l tll
Zoo ~oooo..-l(J).IJ.lJtllU Zoo t:: t:: tlll-l p..4-l ~ 00 .0 .0 .0 4-l t:: l-l p.. 4-l
oE-i
...:lH
8~ 00 00 00 00
Q) Uj::l Q) Q) Q) Q)
CJ IH >-< >-< >-< >-<
t:: i$
tll
t::
Q)
.IJ
t::
.,-l I!
~ t::
.,-l
'\:I 00 00 00 00
4-l r-l Q) Q) Q) Q)
0 .,-l >-< >-< >-< >-<
::l ~~
t:: ~
0 tnO
.,-l r-l
00 tll
..-I
:> .,-l j::l~
..-I CJ 00 00 00 (J)
~ .,-l HO Q) Q) Q) Q)
t:: IlQIlQ >-< I >-< >-< >-<
f
;l -
tn
r-l ~B' , Q) I
.0 1t::Q):>r-l. >-.
::l Q)OCJ.,-ltllt:: l-l
~ ~~ I '\:I.lJtll (IJCJO Q)
.,-l _4-lQ)(J).IJ t:: l-l I :> t::
Ol ~~ .lJQ)Ol-ll-l 1- o Q) .,-l 0
.. t:::>\O::ll-l',-lO .IJ ~ r-l.IJ
~ >. ;:;:: =ae <..-I..-lOOO.IJO -0 Q)-
C.J . (J)~ Ut::N Or-l '\:IU')
I:l < IlQ o Q) 10 I tll~ \0.0 N
~ Qj 0\ l-l l-l 0\ .,-l I . p.. .
~ 0 I l-l Q) I .IJ '\:I 00 N 0 a-<:t
0 e.!) 0 CJ e.!) t:: t:: t:: C""l_ ::lC""l
~~~ .. U CJ.,-lu<t: tll..-l ~~ ~~
I-l 0
iZi~~ Qj ..-l
(J)
H = I
...:llo/:liZi
~...:lS ..-l - I
0\ tn t:: t:: t:: t::
~~~ 0\ '-" 0 0 0 0
..-l ~ .IJ .IJ .IJ I .IJ
U - - - -
00 Ol ~ U') U') 0 U')
i=~~ 1'0 1'0 1'0 ..-l 1'0
N ~ . . . .
N N -<:t U')
H~ .IJ e C""l C""l C""l C""l
U j::l 00 ~ ~ ~ ~
~H ::l IlQ
01lQ i
::l
~ <
U
H Ol
~ >-. >-.
~ tll E-i . t:: Q)
0 '\:I ~~ . tJ tll t::
00 CJ t:: p.. .,-l
Q) t:: H . a;:;::
::l H 0 0
E-l ~iS OlU U.IJ
r-l t:: r-l r-l
~~ tll 0 tll .IJ .IJ tll
t:: .,-l t::r-l r-loo
o 00 o tll tll
~ .,-l.,-l ..-100 00<
~~ .IJ :> . .IJ t::H .
~ tll .,-l CJ tll t:: CJ
t::o t:: t:: tll tll Ol t::
~~ l-l H l-l tJ CJ Q) H
Q) .IJ Q) .,-l -,-l..c:
.. Be.!) .lJr-l 0l.IJ l-l l-l CJ Ol
I:l t:: tll .IJ t:: Q) Q) t:: .IJ
0 iZi HOO r;;jH~ ~~ r-l
'I"'l ~H tll
.IJ O~ t:: t:: 00 t:: ~ 00
ell ...:l o 0 o..c: ..c:
C.J ~~ .IJ.IJ O.IJ.IJ .IJ Q) 0
0 l-l l-l N l-l l-l l-l .IJ N
.IJ ...:l o 0 ~ 0 0 o 0 ~
~"J,q_ r-l ;:;::;:;:: ;:;::z zu
tll lo/:l
00
..
'\:I ,~ .
tll CJ
0 t::
~ E-i H .
0
.. Ol U
Qj r-l t::
oIJ tll 0 .IJ
ell t:: .,-l r-l ,
j::l o 00 tll ,
.. .,-l.,-l 00
oIJ J g3 .IJ :> .
C.J tll .,-l t:: CJ
Qj 2l t::~ . tll t::
',., ~ l-l CJ CJ H
0 H Q) .IJ t:: .,-l
I-l j:l., IlQ .lJr-l H l-l Ol
~ 0 t:: tll Q) .IJ
Hoo Ol ~ r-l
"d "d r-l tll
'I"'l ..-l t:: t:: r-l 00
IlQ IlQ o 0 .,-l ..c:
.IJ.IJ 00 .IJ 0
.. ., l-l l-l l-l l-l N
o 0 tll 0 ~
;:;::;:;:: U Z <
---~,." - ~-=.
.
ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
TO: Members of Dublin City Council
FROM: Timothy C. Hansley, City Manager
SUBJECT: Salt Bids
DATE: September 3, 1991
~ BY: David L. Harding, Director of Personnel & Purchasing ~
~ Summary & Action Recommended
After advertising and receiving bids for road salt, said bids were opened at
10:00 A.M. on Tuesday, August 27, 1991. Bids were requested based upon an
estimated quantity of 4,000 tons for a contract period covering November 1, 1991
through March 31, 1992. (For reference purposes, it should be noted that the
estimated quantity of 4,000 tons, upon which the vendors prepared their bids, is
the same as last year.) Attached for your consideration, please find the bid
tabulation and Ordinance No. 69-91 accepting the lowest & best bid. In staff's
judgement, the bid submitted by Morton International Inc. in the amount of
$32.75jton is, the lowest & best bid; therefore, staff recommends that said bid
be accepted. (Again for reference purposes, it should also be noted that Morton
International, Inc. is the same vendor which provided salt to the City during the
Winter of 1990-91 and Morton's 1991-92 bid of $32.75jton has not increased from
their bid price offered the City during 1990-91 contract period. In addition,
it should be emphasized that Morton International provided timely, excellent
service to the City during the 1990-91 contract period.)
Evaluation of Bids
As referenced on the attached bid tabulation, the City received bids from the
following vendors:
*Morton International, Inc.
*North American Salt Company
*AKZO Salt, Inc.
*Cargill, Inc.
During the bid evaluation process, staff noted that Morton International, Inc.
and Cargill, Inc. had each submitted a low bid of $32.75jton; however, staff also
noted that the bid from Cargill, Inc. deviated from the City's salt
, specifications in that their salt was white in color instead of blue as specified
......... by the City in the salt specifications. The blue color is indicative of the fact
that an anti-caking agent, which the City also requires in its specifications,
has indeed been added to the salt. The blue color is deemed by the City to be
a critical, substantive requirement clearly identified in its specifications.
Since the bid from Cargill, Inc. does not comply with the specifications in this
regard, and the bid from Morton International, Inc. does, the bid from Morton
International, in staff's judgement, is the lowest & best bid.
Conclusion
Based upon the fact that the bid submitted by Morton International is not only
the lowest bid, but that said bid also complies with the City's salt
specifications, staff recommends that said bid of $32.75jton for the contract
period of November 1, 1991 through March 31, 1992 be accepted. Please note that
Ordinance No. 69-91 is not written as emergency legislation. Staff anticipates
that given current supply levels and normal weather patterns in late October -
early November, there should be sufficient time to allow the normal legislative
process to take its course.
DLHjmc
Attachments
/~