05-05 OrdinanceRECORD OF ORDINANCES
Dayton Legal Blank, Inc. Norm NO. 3UU43
05-05 Passed 20
Ordinance No.
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE 1997 COMMUNITY PLAN
(CASE N0.04-180ADM -REVISION OF MAP 8 -FUTURE LAND USE)
WHEREAS, the Dublin City Council has requested that the Future Land Use Map
within the 1997 Community Plan be amended to change the recommended land use
classification of selected properties within a general area bounded by State Route
33/161 to the north, Houchard Road to the west, Shier Rings Road to the south and
Avery Road to the east from "Residential: Medium Density, 1-2 dwelling units per
acre" to "Mixed Use-Employment Emphasis," "Existing Public/Private Parks," and
"Public Park";
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin seeks to preserve the public health, safety, and
welfare by managing the City's growth environment and targeting key areas for future
economic growth and viability;
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin strives to promote an excellent quality of life,
superior economic development, and an outstanding level of services to those who live
or work in the community while ensuring that additional growth does not adversely
affect the community;
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin seeks to pursue and implement recommendations and
strategies contained within the City of Dublin Economic Development Strategy
Update to ensure the municipality's continued competitive economic advantage;
WHEREAS, it is necessary from time to time to update maps within the Community
Plan to reflect the ongoing changes, growth, and community vision of the City.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Dublin,
State of Ohio, r of the elected members concurring:
Section 1. That Map 8: Future Land Use, prepared by the Dublin Planning Division
and last revised on January 7, 2005, of the 1997 Community Plan is hereby adopted to
supersede the amended 1997 Future Land Use Map, as revised on August 12, 2002,
and the recommendations of the Planning and Zoning Commission, Exhibit "C", are
all incorporated into and made an official part of this Ordinance.
Section 2. That this Ordinance shall take effect and be in force from and after the
earliest period allowed by law.
Passed this ~_ day of c,b , 2005.
Mayor -Presiding Officer
Attest:
Cler f Council
Sponsor: Planning Division
I hereby certify that copies of this
Ordinance/Resolution were posted in the
City of Dublin in accordance with Section
731.25 of the Ohio Revised Code.
Duty Clerk of Council, Dublin, Ohio
Department of Development
Land Use and Long Range Planning
5800 Shier-Rings Road • Dublin, Ohio 43016
Phone: 614-410-4600 • Fax: 614-410-4747
f,ITY OF DUBLIN
TO: Members of Dublin City Council ___
FROM: Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager ~ ~`'~`~' ~"~"~°"'"'J
DATE: February 3, 2005
INITIATED BY: Daniel D. Bird, FAICP, Planning Directo~~
Memo
RE: Second Reading -Ordinance OS-OS An Ordinance Amending the 1997
Community Plan (Case 04-180ADM -Revision of Map 8 -Future Land Use)
SUMMARY:
The proposed amendment to the Future Land Use Map of the 1997 Community Plan is intended
to prevent future land use conflicts and to preserve the economic development capability of
areas along the US33 corridor. Areas A, B, and E include changes to "Mixed Use Employment
Emphasis" from single-family residential uses with a density of 1.0 to 2.0 du/ac. The proposed
modifications also address the expansion of Darree Fields and changes to municipal land that
have occurred since 1997 (Areas C and D). The modifications are intended to provide for
compatible uses on a temporary basis that will foster the ability to conduct further land use and
traffic modeling as part of the Community Plan process.
C
BACKGROUND:
Alterations to municipal boundaries due to annexation, modifications to reflect completed
development projects, and the revised location of the Glacier Ridge Metropark were made on the
Future Land Use map in August of 2002. Over the past eight years, significant development
activity has continued along the western periphery of the city, creating the need to re-evaluate the
validity of land uses on certain parcels. Based upon land use complications recently recognized
due to proposed development applications, staff is recommending a modification to the Future
Land Use map.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of Ordinance OS-OS as noted on the attached map
AS SUBMITTED TO CpUNCIi
FOA MEETING ON 2~}
G
'N
~~
S ~ 161 I \~\~~-\II R
R
E RI
R RI R perimeter D ~~e
. r ora d RI PCD I I
D
PCD
?7T~ ~ R-S R
PIP
c B , ~ %%~
PCD
U
PC
04-180 ADM
' City of Dublin Future Land Use Map ~i
Land Use & Long Range Planning Amendment o ,,z5o 2,500 et
`r .
CITY OF DUBLIN
Division of Engineering
5800 Shier Rings Road, Dublin, OH 43016
Phone: 614-410-4600 • Fax: 614-761-6506
emo
To: Mr. Daniel D. Bird, FAICP, Planning Director
From: Jean-Ellen Willis, PE, Assistant Director of Engineering - Transportatio
Date: February 3, 2005
Re: Trip Rate Comparison from Shier Rings Road to US 33/SR 161 and west to
Houchard Road
Ordinance OS-O5: An Ordinance Amending the 1997 Community Plan
(Case No. 04-180ADM -Revision of Map 8 -Future Land Use)
L~
In accordance with your request, I am providing the following comparison of the trip generation rates
for the proposed areas of modification to the Future Land Use Map. Trip generation rates are compared
rather than volumes because how these areas may develop is unknown at this time. Traffic volume
comparisons will occur during the Travel Demand Model update and site-specific traffic impact studies.
These areas are designated as A through E on the map below. A general comparison of the resultant
traffic generation rates, as given in the Institute of Transportation Engineers, Trip Generation, 6`"
Edition, for those areas is briefly addressed.
Memorandum to Dann Bird, Planning Director
2/3/2005
Page 2 of 3
`A' -Northeast of Eiterman Road and Shier-Rings Road
`B' -Northwest Eiterman Road and Shier-Rings Road
`E' -Southwest Corner SR161 and Cosgray Road
Revised to Mixed Use Employment Emphasis from Residential Mediurn Density (1-2 du/ac)
and Existing Public/Institutional. A comparison of trip generation rates for the above uses is
as follows:
1997 Future Land Use Map:
• Code 210 -Single Family Home: Average Rate for a weekday is 9.57 trips household
Proposed Land Uses:
• Code 110 -General Light Industrial
Gross Floor Area
Average Rate for a weekday is 6.97 trips/Sq. Ft.
• Code 710 -General Office Building: Average Rate for a weekday is 11.01 trips/Sq. Ft.
Gross Floor Area
• Code 760 -Research and Development Center: Average Rate for a weekday is 8.11
trips/Sq. Ft. Gross Floor Area
The main difference between the single-family land use and the proposed land uses is the
peak hour generation. Although the daily trip rates for the proposed land uses does not
greatly deviate from Map 8, Future Land Use, as denoted in the Community Plan, the single
family home land use generates a more even trip distribution throughout the day than that of
business uses, which highly favor the morning and afternoon peak hours.
`C' -Darree Fields
`D' -Soccer Stadium Site
In Area C, Darree Fields has been expanded to include additional acreage for the
construction of soccer fields. The map has been changed from Residential Medium Density
(1-2 du/ac) to Existing Public/Private Parks. Southern portions of Area C have not been
developed and may accommodate the extension of Shier-Rings Road and/or additional
recreational amenities. The map has been revised from Residential Medium Density (1-2
du/ac) to Future Public Park in that area. In Area D, the City owns the land in question and
southern portions of the site are being considered for the expansion of the existing soccer
complex, as well as other potential uses. The Future Land Use Map has been revised to show
a change in land use classification from Residential Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) to Future
Public Park. A comparison of trip generation rates is as follows:
1997 Future Land Use Map
• Code 210 -Single Family Home: Average Rate for a weekday is 9.57 trips household
Proposed Modification
• Code 411 -City Park: Average Rate for a weekday is 1.59 trips/Acre
x
Memorandum to Dann Bird, Planning Director
2/3/2005
Page 3 of 3
The proposed land use trip generation rate is much less than that of asingle-family homes
during the weekday. The weekend trip generation is higher for a City Park as compared to a
single-family home. However, other surrounding land uses trip generation will be
significantly lower for a weekend than that during the work week (being Monday through
Friday), and therefore, the additional trip volume generated by the City Park on the weekend
will not pose a burden to the overall transportation system.
Other Relevant Factors:
While the revised land uses as proposed above generates additional peak hour traffic for
Areas A, B, and E, it should be noted, that densities in Dublin overall, have developed less
intensely than anticipated in the 1997 Community Plan. For example, when comparing the
assumptions used in the Community Plan and 2003 projections, land uses between US 33 to
the south, Post Road to the north, Avery-Muirfield Drive to the west, and Emerald Parkway
to the east, there are:
• 85,000 sf more retail space (auto dealerships)
• 230,000 sf less industrial space, and
• 1,120,000 sf less office space.
Further, as part of the Northwest Franklin County Traffic Study, areas of inconsistencies
between Map 8, Future Land Use and land uses coded in the Travel Demand Model were
discovered. For example, in MORPC Traffic Analysis Zone (TAZ) 8427, 1,500,000 sq.ft. of
office was used. When reviewed 8 years later, Map 8 shows this area to be Residential -
Medium Density (1-2 du/acre). This resulted in a significant reduction of traffic on the
Dublin roadway network.
These recommended land use changes do not appear to be cause of immediate concern with
regard to degrading Dublin's roadway network. A detailed examination will occur during the
Community Plan Update through the Travel Demand Model and the Land Use components.
These revised land uses will be input to the travel demand model and their associated trip
generation rates will be evaluated on the roadway network. If modifications are necessary, it
will be at this time that land uses can be revised in other areas of the City to achieve the
desired affect on the roadway network. A final determination of appropriate land uses and
road networks in the Community Plan update will include the analysis of all fiscal, planning,
economic development, and engineering considerations.
CITY OF DUBLIN
Department of Development
Land Use and Long Range Planning
5800 Shier-Rings Road • Dublin, Ohio 43016
Phone: 614-410-4600 • Fax: 614-410-4747
TO: Members of Dublin City Council
FROM: Jane S. Brautigam, City Manage~cw~c-~5 ~~~~,.~
DATE: January 14, 2005 %~j~j
INITIATED BY: Daniel D. Bird, FAICP, Planning Director ~~~`~-''
Memo
RE: First Reading - Ordinance OS-OS An Ordinance Amending the 1997
Community Plan (Case 04-180ADM -Revision of Map 8 -Future Land Use)
SUMMARY:
The proposed amendment to the Future Land Use Map of the 1997 Community Plan is intended
to prevent future land use conflicts and to preserve the economic development capability of
areas along the US33 corridor. Areas A, B, and E include changes to "Mixed Use Employment
Emphasis" from single-family residential uses with a density of 1.0 to 2.0 du/ac. The proposed
modifications also address the expansion of Darree Fields and changes to municipal land that
have occurred since 1997 (Areas C and D). The modifications are intended to provide for
compatible uses that will foster the ability to conduct further traffic modeling and study as part
of the on-going Community Plan process.
BACKGROUND:
Alterations to municipal boundaries due to annexation, modifications to reflect completed
development projects, and the revised location of the Glacier Ridge Metropark were made on the
Future Land Use map in August of 2002. Over the past eight years, significant development
activity has continued along the western periphery of the city, creating the need to re-evaluate the
validity of land uses on certain parcels. Based upon land use complications recently recognized
due to proposed development applications, staff is recommending a modification to the Future
Land Use map.
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of Ordinance OS-OS as noted on the attached map
C1TY OF DUBLIN._
Division of Planning
~,, - ,5800 Shier-Rings Road
Alin, Ohio 43016-1236
••-,e/TDD: 614-410-4600
Fax: 614-761-6566
Web Site: www.dublin.oh.us
PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
RECORD OF ACTION
JANUARY 13, 2005
The Planning and Zoning Commission took the following action at this meeting:
2. Administrative Request 04-180ADM -Future Land Use Map Amendment
Request: Review and approval of an amendment to the Future Land Use Map to modify
land use classifications for an area generally bounded by State Route 161 and US 33 to
the north, Houchard Road to the west, Shier Rings Road to the south and Avery Road to
the east to "Mixed Use Employment Emphasis" and "Municipal Park."
Applicant: City of Dublin, c/o Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager, 5200 Emerald
Parkway, Dublin, Ohio 43017.
Staff Contact: Carson Combs, Senior Planner.
Contact Information: Phone: 410-4669/E-mail: ccombs@dublin.oh.us.
MOTION: To forward this Administrative Request to City Council with a positive
recommendation to adopt Ordinance OS-OS modifying the land use classifications for the area
generally bounded by State Route 161 and US 33 to the north, Houchard Road to the west, Shier-
Rings Road to the south and Avery Road to the east to "Mixed Use Employment Emphasis,"
"Existing Public/Private Park," and "Public Park."
VOTE: 4-0.
RESULT: This Administrative Request was approved. It will be forwarded to City Council
with a positive recommendation.
ST F CERTIFICATI
iel D. rd, P
Director of Lan Use and
Long Range Planning
DUBLIN PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION
STAFF REPORT
JANUARY 13, 2005
CITY OF DUBLIlV_
tlirisioa of f'laaaiag
S>f00 Sher-Rings Road
Oubt~, Oleo 43016-1236
f :614-410-4600
f 14-410-4147
Y -- :ite: www.dub5n_ofi.us
2. Administrative Request 04180ADM -Future Land Use Map Amendment
Request: Review and approval of an amendment to the Future Land Use Map to modify
land use classifications far an azea generally bounded by Stag Route 161 and US 33 to
the north, Houchazd Road to the west, Shier Rings Road to the south and Avery Road to
- the east to "Mixed Use Employment Emphasis," "Existing PublicfPrivate Park," and
_ "Public Pazk." ~ - .
Applicant: City of Dublin, c% Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager, 5200 Emerald.-
Pazkway, Dublin, Ohio.43017.
Staff Contact: Carson Combs, Senior Planner. -
Contact Information: Phone: 410-4669/E-mail: ccombs@dublin.oh.us.
BACKGROUND:
This is a request for recommendation to City Council on the proposed modification of Map 8 -
Future Land Use of the 1997 Community Plan. Determined land uses in the original Community
Plan document included decisions based upon traffic modeling for the City and surrounding area.
The general azea in the vicinity of the US 33 Corridor includes parcels that were Largely
designated for medium density residential development at 1-2 du~ac. Alterations. to municipal
boundaries due to annexation, modifications to reflect completed development projects, and the
revised location of the Glacier Ridge Metropazk were made on the .Future Land Use map. in
August of 2002. Over the past eight years, significant development activity has continued along
the western periphery of the city, creating the need to re-evaluate the validity of land uses on
certain parcels. Based upon land use complications recently recognised due to proposed
development applications, staff is recommending a modification to the Future Land Use map.
The proposed changes are intended to prevent potential land use conflicts and to preserve the
economic development capability of azeas along the US33 corridor in a manner that will foster
the ability to conduct finrther study and refinement through the on-going process to update the
Community Plan.
Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission
Staff Report -January 13, 2445
Case 2 -Page 2
CONSIDERATIONS:
The following are proposed areas of modification to the Future Land Use Map as denoted in the
map. The considerations below briefly addresses areas as lettered A through E:
A) Northeast of Eiterman Road and Shier-Rings Road -Revised to Mixed Use Employment
Emphasis from Residential Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) and Existing Public/Institutional. Areas
to be modified include existing oflYCe and industrial uses along Eiterman Road that aze not
consistent with the existing map. ~: Undeveloped portions that aze currently shown as future
residential pose significant land use conflicts and issues relating to development that include the
following:
• Development of residential in this area would create a loss of significant economic frontage
along US 33, limiting the City's future economic development potential. In no other location
in the city do residential developments exist along such important frontages.
• Future residences would be located adjacent to the future Washington Township fire training
facility, creating the potential for land use conflicts.
• Existing general industrial uses and warehousing would be located adjacent to future
residences, creating the potential for noise complaints.
• A future helipad for the Dublin Community Hospital would be located opposite the azea
along US 33.
• Expected future traffic levels could necessitate the installation of noise barriers in the future
along US 33 to reduce noise levels along any potential residential development.
• The existing municipal service center along Shier-Rings Road will also create the potential
for incompatible land uses, buffering and noise complaints.
B) Northwest Eiterman Road and Shier-Rings Road -The 1997 Community Plan projected
Residential Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) for the area and proposed modifications include Mixed
Use Employment Emphasis. The existing Sports Ohio complex creates the potential for
significant lighting conflicts with adjacent residential development. Additional concerns include
the existing Planned Industrial Pazk (PIP) zoning, future fire training facility, existing industrial
uses, and significant outdoor recreation events. Other adjacent azeas have already been
'Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission
Staff Report -January 13, 2005
Case 2 -Page 3
designated as mixed-use employment emphasis, which could account for a creative mix of
office, retail and other supportive uses. Retention of the residenfial classification, however,
would result in single-family neighborhood development north of Shier-Rings Road with little
spatial relationship with other residential development in the area. Staff is concerned that
creating another development surrounded by industrial and service uses similaz to that of Heather
Glen will result in noise concerns, light trespass, and substantial traffic calming issues. The
proposed modifications are intended to provide for a compatible interim use that will allow
further study and refinement as part of the planning process for the area.
C) Darree Fields -Since the 1997 Community Plan, Darree Fields has been expanded to
include additional acreage for the construction of soccer fields. The map has been changed from
Residential Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) to Existing Public/Private Parks. Southern portions of
the site have not been developed and may accommodate the extension of Shier-Rings. Road
and/or additional recreational amenities. The map has been revised from Residential Medium
Density (1-2 du/ac) to Future Public Park in that azea.
D) Soccer Stadium Site -Revised to show a change in land use classification from Residential
Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) to Future Public Park. Land in question is owned by the City and
southern portions of the .site are being considered for the expansion of the existing soccer
complex. The proposed change could be considered as a holding classification by City Council
until final direction for the future of the property is.determined.
E) Southwest Corner SR161 and Cosgray Road -Revised to show a change in land use
classification from Residential Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) to Mixed Use Employment Emphasis.
Denoted pazcels do not provide sufficient depth along a major arterial to accommodate
residential development with proper buffering and would create complications similar to portions
rezoned along Hazd Road in the Northeast Quadrant PUD. Modification will allow for proper
frontage development that can be coordinated with the Route 161/33 Edge Plan.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of Ordinance OS-OS (See attachment) that modifies the land use
classifications for the -area generally bounded by State Route 161 and US 33 to the north,
Houchard Road to the west, Shier-Rings Road to the south and Avery Road to the east to "Mixed
Use Employment Emphasis," "Existing Public/Private Park," and "Public Park," and a
forwarding recommendation to City Council for adoption. During the 1997 Community Plan
process, little agreement was reached on land uses in this azea of the plan. As a result, future
land uses were designated to facilitate the traffic modeling efforts. Staff believes that the
proposed changes will alleviate potential future land use conflicts in a variety of areas and will
accommodate additional time for evaluation as part of the Community Plan Update process. The
proposed modifications better reflect existing development and will continue the high quality of
life for existing and future residents, as well as to ensure the City's continued competitive
economic advantage in the central Ohio region, consistent with the recently adopted City of
Dublin Economic Development Strategy Update.
Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission Q
Minutes -January 13, 2005 D / IAF~
Page 5
2. Administrative Request 04-180ADM -Future Land Use Map Amendment
Carson Combs said this was a request to review and approve amendments to the Future Land
Use Map for the area north of Shier-Rings Road, south of SR 161, and west of US 33. He said
over the last few years there have been a lot of changes along the western periphery of the City,
and some instances of concern regarding land use have come up that staff is looking to address,
at at least, temporarily. Staff expects to re-evaluate the area land use as part of the Community
Plan update, which will allow for more in depth analysis of traffic and fiscal issues.
Mr. Combs said the first reading for this amended ordinance has been scheduled to go before
City Council next week. He said following their recommendation, it will move forward for a
vote from City Council at a second reading.
He said there were three versions of the Future Land Use Map included in the staff report: the
original 1997 map, modifications that were made in 2002, and the proposed revisions requested
by staff.
Block A -The northeast corner of Shier-Rings Road and Eiterman Road currently is shown as
Residential, one to two units per acre. He said a there are a number of land use conflicts
identified that staff believes will negatively impact residential development. He said there are
office buildings existing within that proposed classification, as well as a future fire-training
facility. A helipad for the future hospital will be located across US 33, creating noise issues. He
said the overall projection for traffic on US 33 may additionally require a sound barrier system
similax to the I-270 outer belt. In addition, there is the City service center and a variety of
industrial warehouse uses immediately to the south and east. In terms of economic development,
the site has frontage onto US 33 for office development, and staff recommends changing the
designation to Mixed-Use Employment Emphasis.
Block B -The northwest portion of Eiterman and Shier-Rings Road is also shown as
Residential, one to two units per acre. Mr. Combs said there are a number of issues that will
impact residential development including existing research and development and industrial/light
manufacturing uses. Again, the future fire training facility is located nearby. An industrial park
exists with significant potential for light trespass and high intensity recreational activities
(SportsOhio). Mr. Combs said staff is also recommending that the area be modified to Mixed-
Use Employment Emphasis.
Block C -Darree Fields and City-owned parcels to the west along Houchard Road
Mr. Combs said this block includes an area in Darree Fields area has been expanded to the west
for additional soccer fields. The City has additional land to the south that may or may not be
added with additional recreational facilities.
Mr. Combs said on the current Thoroughfare Plan, the extension of Shier-Rings Road is shown
into the park area and it will terminate at Houchard Road.
Mr. Combs said staff is looking to extend the "Existing Park" and the "Future Park"
classification for these areas.
Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission
Minutes -January 13, 2005 DRAFT
Page 6
Block D -Former soccer stadium site
Mr. Combs said there are no current plans for this site, but the Future Land Use Map projects a
residential density of one to two units per acre. He said given the overall estimate of what is
projected for this area, staff does not believe at this time, that a Residential classification is
suitable. As a holding classification, staff is recommending "Future Park" until such time an
overall plan for the area is determined through the Community Plan process.
Block E -Small area of frontage along SR 161
Mr. Combs said this area is also shown as Residential, one to two units per acre, creating
substantial issues. An industrial park lies directly to the south, with SR 161 expected to be a
major arterial. The lack of lot depth and the amount of frontage does not provide a sufficient
area for residential development. Staff recommends a temporary use of Mixed-Use Employment
Emphasis.
Ted Saneholtz said the switch to the mixed-use employment emphasis vs. single-family homes
amongst the commercial development made sense and seemed much more consistent. He
appreciated Mr. Combs' efforts.
Mr. Gerber said Mr. Combs had done a good job of explaining why this is needed and why the
proposed changes are necessary.
Mr. Gerber made a motion recommending City Council adopt and approve this Administrative
Request. Mr. Zimmerman seconded the motion, and the vote was as follows: Mr. Sprague, yes;
Mr. Saneholtz, yes; Mr. Zimmerman, yes; and Mr. Gerber, yes. (Approved 4-0.)
~ ~ Q ~
e
~ R
,,~~k-~.._ _ ~,. 0.
~ ~
';-~f.
it ReferY+fi: ---- .
;; ~'~. Hillia
"' Master Pla
.. . r..
_-__ -___ _ ___~~. i ~ ~ ~ ~
_..r' ~
LEG END
~' Res al--High Density (5+ du/ac)
~~
o~t Private Institutional C O M M U N I T Y
Dublin Boundary [ y
Office Public Park P L A N
- -- Planned Roads ~ Research & Development Private Park CTI'Y OF
-, , , . Area Plan Boundary 0 Light Industrial Existing Land Use DUBLIN
Rural Residential/Agriculture Retail ~ Residential OHIO
Residential--Low Density (0.5-1 du/ac) Mixed Use-Employment Emphasis ~ Non-Residential
~ Residential--Medium Density (1-2 du/ac) Mixed Use-Residential Emphasis 0 Public/Institutional Buildings
0 Residential--High Density (2-5 du/ac) 0 Public ~ Public/Private Parks April 15,1999
MAP 8 Future Land Use N
o zsoo 00o O
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
M1nntPC of , :, Meph_ng
1Y[iRRII'G
Held August 12, 2002 ,
5EC ll KLrAI)11V1i/ iSLll. nr. ~v-.,a.,.. ~,,.....,.,
O ance 97-02 - Ordinance cceptiag the west and t Bid for ock Salt,
a Authorizing a City Mana to Enter i a Contract or Procure ent of Said
ommodity.
Ms. Brautiga noted that have been o changes s e the first g. Staff
recommen ' adoption ai time.
Vote on a Ordinance: .Reiner, ; Mr. ICrans er, yes; Boring, y , Ms.
Chinnic' uercher, yes; s. Salay, yes' ayor McCas yes; Mr. Le ider, yes.
Or Hance 100-02 An Ordina to Change a Name o itchell-De Road to
and Road Be een the Fra in County/U on County ne and Hyla -Croy Road
n the City of blin.
Ms. Brautig noted that ere have be no Chang since the firs eading: Staff i
recommen ng adoption this time.
Vote o e Ordinanc . Mrs. Sorin yes; Mr. anstuber, yes' s. Salay, yes; s.
Chinn' t-Zuercher, y ;Mayor McC yes; Mr. klider, yes; .Reiner, yes.
O finance 101 - An Ord' ce Autho ' ing the City anager to En r into a
onduit Use reement wi per"ion, I
Ms. Brautig noted that ere have b no changes s' a the first readin . She further
comment that the City i ortunate to a the opport ty for this innova ' e project.
Vote on a Ordinance: s. Chinnici uercher, yes; . Kranstuber, y Mr. Reiner, ,
Ms. S ay, yes; Mr. lider, yes; yor McCash; ;Mrs. Boring, y
dinance 102 - An Ordi ce Regulatin Future Access t the Norther End of
rails End Dr e, and Repe ng Ordinance o. 86-02(Amend ).
Ms. Brautig noted ere have bee no changes since a first re g. Staff is
recommen ' g adoption.
Mayor Cash inqui if the purpo of the new ord' ante is to f litate the r
vacati
Mr. mith respon that legal conducted ad ' onal researc on this iss and
co luded that a ore effective ears of regulatin lure access the northe end of
ails End D ' e would be ugh passage of 's legislatio This pros ure was
determined t be both easier d more cost eff 've than vac g the righ f-way and
requesting a property o ers to deed the t-of--way b to the Ci Mr. Smith
clarified at this ordinan repeals Ordinance 6-OZ (Amend
Vote the Ordinanc Mr. Lecklider, y ; Ms. Salay, s; Mayor Cash, yes; Mrs.
Bo ' g, yes; Mr. Re' r, yes; Ms. Chronic' uercher, yes; . ICranstub ,Yes.
Ordinance 109-02 (Amended) - An Ordinance Amending the 1997 Community Plan.
(Case No. 02-065 -ADM -Revision of Map 8 -Future Land Use)
Mayor McCash noted that there has been a request for public comment on the proposed
legislation.
Bob West 7508 Kilbrittain Lane, Dublin, stated that he is a trustee with the Wellington
Place Homeowners Association. He thanked Mrs. Boring and other Council members for
working with the association during the last few months.
Ms. Salay stated that, unrelated to this issue, Mts. Boring suggested another amendment to
the Community Plan last fall regarding the proposed bridge location at Tuttle Crossing
Boulevard. That item remains of great interest to the residents in Llewellyn Fatms and to
the anticipated homeowners in the new Llewellyn Farms South subdivision. At that time,
staff was waiting for completion of a traffic assessment. Has that been completed?
Mr. Hammersmith responded that staff is still awaiting an update of the City's travel
demand model from MORPC. It will not be completed until Spring 2003. More conclusive
traffic numbers will be available at that time.
Vote on the Ordinance: Mr. Kranstuber, yes; Mr. Reiner, yes; Ms. t:hinttici-Zuercher, yes;
Mayor McCash, yes; Mrs. Boring, yes; Ms. Salay, yes; Mr. Lecklider, yes.
04-180 ADM
Future Land Use
T !_~ A-__~1W .-a
RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS
Minutes of Dublin qty Council Page 11 Meeting
Held ~I/ ~ 2002 19
Vote on the action: Mr. .yes-, Mr. Reiner. Yes; Mr tuber. Yes; Ms.
Zuercher; Yes: Mrs_ Boring. Mayor McCash, Yes.
Wks. Badrg inkodrroed O 105-02 ttuorrgh 10 and moved referral to nning
8 Zoning Commission
Wk: Leddider the motion.
V the Mr. Krartshiber, yes; tNs. .. zuercher, Yes: Wta McCash, Yes;
Mrs. Boring, . Mr. Leddider, Yes; Mr. Re .Yes.
urdina 105-02 - An Ordinan o Establish Dublin Zo g for Five Parcels
Go ing an Area of Approxim y 140 Acres, as Annex om Jerome Townshi
i 01, Generatiy.Located Ea of Hyland-Croy Road, 2 Feet North of Mach -
ewitt Road, as R, Rural Di ct. (Case ~- 02-0672) ( rent: City of Dublin)
106-02 - An Ordinance to stabiish Dublin Zoning f Approximately 42.387 cres,
as Annexed from Co Township in 2002, Gen ly Located East of Du n Road,
Approximately 700 F South of Glick Road, as Rural District. (Case . 02-068Z)
(App6canl COY of )
Ordinance 107 - An OMinance to Esta Dublin Zoning for 27 rcels
CompNsing Area of Approximately 36 Acres, as Mnexed fr Washington
Township 1 001 2002, on the East a est Sides of Dublin R d, as R-1,
Restri Suburban Residential his (Case No. 02-0692) icant: City of Dublin)
Ordin ce 108-02 - An Ordinance tablish Dublin Zonnn or Three Parcels
Co ing an Area of Approxi ely 28.4 Acres, as An ed from Washington
nship in 2001, on the W ide of Cosgray Road, proximately 975 Feet North
f Rings Road, as R, Rural icl (Case No. 02-070 (Applicant: City of Dublin)
Ordinance 109-02 - An Ordinance Amending the 1997 Community Ptan. (Case No.
02-065 -ADM -Revision of Map 8 -Future Land Use)
Mrs. Boring introduced the ordinance.
Ms. Grigsby stated that Ms. Clarke inducted a memo explaining the revisioru proposed in
this ordinance. Planning & Zoning Corrurdss'ron has already reviewed the map.
Mrs. Boring asked why this would not be referred to P8Z
Ms. garke stated that Couna'1 is required to refer rezonings to P8Z, but this relates to a
plan amendment, the content of which has akeady been reviewed by P8Z if Council
desires, the ordinance can be referred to P8Z. In response to Mayor McCash, she noted
that the map reflects the Land use change for the area north of Brand Road and west of
Wellington, the overa8 boundary change for Dtnblin as a result of recent annexations, and
the Glader Ridge Metro Park Master Plan.
Mr. Reiner asked far cont'rcrnation of any changes for residential areas.
Ms. Clarke resporxied that the only residential areas shifted from one dassification to
another was the area along Brand Road near Coffman -moved from a high density
residential to a medium density residential. This was done in response to Coundl's
direction.
Mrs. Boring asked about the d~ange In the Ballantrae area.
Ms. Clarke responded that Baflantrae had the same land use prevrousty. The map reflects
the densities indicated in the adopted BaNantrae plan_ The overall density sb'N falls within 1-
2 units per acre. Coundl can dxxue to reflect this site by site, or as an overall density of
1-2 units per acre.
There wiQ be a second reading/public hearing at the August 12 Coundi meeting.
Nlr. Smith indipted that next five resolutions relat o the MuirfieldiGlidc
intersection. '
Mayor McCash to waive the Rules of Ord and to have the perk to
the record the names only for R ns 27-02 through 31-02, to
introduce the resolutkxu. .
Resolution -02 - A Resolution of int to Appropriate A 0.085 A e, More or
Less, T ovary Construction Eas nt, from. Martin and Debo
Conna hton, Located South of G Road and West of Mu d Drive, City
of O n, County of Franidin, S e of Ohb. (Mutrfietd/Glick ersection)
Re lotion 28-02 - A Resoluti of intent to Appropriate a mbined 0.030
e, More or.Less, Tempo Construction Easement, om Delorfs J.
Godfrey, Located Nortit o ick Road and West of Co Drive, City of
Dublin. County of Fran State of Ohio. (Muhfleld/ do Intersection)
Resolution 29-02 - A ohrtion of Intent to App ate a 0.013 Arxe, More or
Less, Temporary C struction Easement, frotrt aloud and Floc R~^
04180 ADM
Future Land Use
Map Amendment
QTY OF DUBLIN
Olrisio~ ~f Mai9
5000 5lne~~Gags ~
ah~i""°°xia 4301 b-123b
ny :614-~10~600
tmi:614-761-bSfb
b Sife: rrnw_du6Gaab.us
PLANNING AND ZONIIVG CONIIVIISSION
RECORD OF ACTION
JUNE 20, 2002
The Planning and Zoning Commission took the following action at this meeting:
MOTION: To approve the revised Future Land Use Map dated June 20, 2002.
VOTE: 40.
RESULT: The Future Land Use Map was approved as presented. It will be forwarded to City
Council with a positive recommendation.
STAFF CERTIFICATION
~~~
Barbara M. Clarke
Planning Director
04180 ADM
Future Land Use
Map Amendment
DUBLIN PLl~NNING AND ZONIIVG COMMISSION
.,~rPli OF DUBLIN
MEETING 11~IINUTES
JUNE 20, 2002
-)
Division d R~9
Si100 Sher-Ggs Rood
~, Ohio 4301 ~-1236
r/(~:614-410-1600
Faz:614-761-656
Weh SAe: vn~nsduhiiah.ua
1. Prese aNon - 02 ADM -Mid- hio Regional arming Co - sion - r ii-
Fri dly Design o vote or acti taken)
2. nditional U 02-027CU - T cci's Patio - 35 orth High eet (Approv 5-0)
3. evelopmen lan 02-04ifiDP - Mei_jer's Sto Outlot - 6 5, 6189, 6191 and 6195
Sawmill R d (Approved )
4. Revised al Developm t Plan 02-049 P -Meijer arking Lot ( proved 5-0)
. Revis Development an 02-053RDP Riverside P , Subarea B Avery Square
I{ro r - 7100 Pe ' ter Loop Road• and Perimet Center, Sub F -Perimeter
C ter Big Bear - 00 Perimeter op Road (A roved 5-0)
C Tim Sprague c vened the rose ~ at 6:30 p.m. er Commis' Hers present were: - oda
~, Jo essineo, and ck Gerber. D' k Ritchie and ed Saneholtz were sent.
athy Boring 'ved at 7:05 p Staff me rs present in uded: Bobbie Cl ,Gary
Gunderman, on Combs, a Wanner, rey Theuer uf, Mitch Banche ky, Paul
Hamm Barb Cox, an ibby Farley.
A five Business
Mr. r made the tion to accept documents in a record. Mr. Z' erman seconded
~; the otion, and the v to was unanino in favor. (App ved 4-0.)
After discusin nsent agenda i , Ivir. Sprague ounced the order f cases as: Cases 1, 5,
3, 4, and 2. a minutes re t the publish agenda order.] .Sprague explained the
meeting p ores and that n new cases wool introduced after :00 p.m.
Land Use Mau
Bobbie Clarke presented a proposed revision to the Community Plan Land Use Map. City
Council directed that the land use on Brand Road should be downgraded from high density
residential use, to medium density at one to two units per acre. Also, the Glacier Ridge Metro
Park area was updated to reflect the latest adopted park master plan. The Ballentrae area was
updated, and Dublin's boundaries were adjusted to reflect new annexations. She asked if the
Commission had any other areas for correction or more study. She promised ~ She asked f r
1 back to City Council in July. She said Anne Wanner did all of the mapping
-- _ a recommendation motion.
04-180 ADM
Future Land Use
~ Map Amendment
,.
Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission
Minutes -June 20, 2002
Page 2
Mr. Gerber said the revised map was acceptable and in line with what the Commission had
discussed at its last meeting. Mr. Zimmerman agreed. Mr. Gerber made a motion to approve
this revised Future Land Use Map. Mr. Zimmerman seconded, and the vote was as follows: Mr.
Gerber, yes; Ivir. Zimmerman, yes; Mr. Sprague, yes; and Mr. Messineo, yes. (Approved 4-0).
Mr. Sprague thanked Ms. Wanner for her work. He said it was a large, often thankless task.
1. P
F
Chris Cn
two' ~
un rdi
a
road cc
mobility
'proper d~
se tion - 02-06 M -Mid-O o Regional Pl ing Commissio -Transit
dly Design
ronski, of M C, said rtation and dev opment are close linked and are
that i~eprese .~a struggle in 'region. He said a two issues ofte have separate an
ited decis' n-making pr s. He said an i transportation stem would pro ' e
n leve of usefiilness...fo all members, at minimum cost. needs to consid the
m over a long ~ , . including a wing population people with sand
ems. Mr. Ga nski said a stro transportation stem can be achi ed with
lopment pl He said transpo 'on diversity is a key.
He ,d, for example, any Italian VPllag~residents bought ' that neighborho because it has
it `access and si walks. Many ple do not have d do not want a o-car garage. He
'd Warren Stree developed by S van and Bruck, p vided one parkin space per bedroom,
but it is more needed becaus many residents the available rtation system. e
said Lennox. orked with COT to tap the OSU m et across the riv successfiilly.
Mr. Ga nski said trans - nation linked d elopment
Mr. Ga nski offered to rk with staff on tore projects. Mr.
joint jests between M C and Dublin.. . Gawronski sai~
F elaware traffi and growth ment project.
'on centers b ' g several types o ~ rtatio
ma. interesting to blip due to its epath system.
on aad Linden. a said COTA a multi-modal to
eluding a day and health cen ` He said the to
and transpo n systems are n Brous, and he ' pr en
model TOD erlay ordinance an _ transportation ch ist
~Ir. Gawronski sal ORPC is quasi- overnmenti
region. It ov the distribution o federal transp
plan, and moni rs air quality for a region. Trans
said Dublin d other manic' 'ties submit tra
bikepaths d roadway beau ' cation,. annually He
is avail a for projects o than those projects
doll than enhancemen rojects proposed
Clarke noted
'd there may be
Gawronski for his
hn pays dues to
opportunity for IJ
presentation. (Ms. F
ineo asked aboytE any
i was involved' in the
;tropo ' planning or
ion oney, does a 20-~
n funding is linked
tion projects forll
~Id also, transport
is not uncommon
~'C and provides
for enhancement
arrived at 7:05 n.
comes m a variety of fo ,and
n to er. He said a bic cle center
said that COTA a TOD in
at lla' and Cle land Avenue,
term benefits of 1' g development
ted information p kets. There is
when conside ' a development.
tton for this
transportation
air quality. He
ling, including
icement money
C to have more
on its development. She
Mr. Sprague thanked Mr.
04180 ADM
Future Land Use
Map Amendment