HomeMy WebLinkAbout31-08 OrdinanceRECORD OF ORDINANCES
Bunk. [nc.
Form No. 10043
Ordinance No. 31-08 Passed . 20
AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER
TO ENTER INTO APRE-ANNEXATION AGREEMENT
DESCRIBING THE INTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES TO
ANNEX CERTAIN REAL PROPERTY OWNED BY BVH
ASSOCIATES, LOCATED IN PERRY TOWNSHIP.
WHEREAS, BVH Associates is the owner of certain real property located at 6924
Riverside Drive in Perry Township (the "Property"), being more fully described in the
Agreement attached hereto as "Exhibit A"; and
WHEREAS, the Property is located adjacent to and beyond the present corporate
boundaries of The City of Dublin ("City"); and
WHEREAS, BVH Associates desires to annex the Property to the City in order to obtain
municipal services to support the Property; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to annex the Property in order to obtain and serve the
economic potential of the Property and surrounding roadway for its citizens and residents.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Dublin, State
of Ohio, ~ of the elected members concurring:
Section 1. The City Manager is hereby authorized to execute the attached Pre-
annexation Agreement on behalf of the City stating the intention of the parties to annex
certain lands owned by BVH Associates.
Section 2. This Ordinance shall take effect and be in force from and after the earliest date
permitted by law.
Passed this day of , 2008.
Mayor -- Presiding Officer
ATTEST:
Clerk of Council
Office of the City Manager
5200 Emerald Parkway • Dublin, OH 43017
Phone: 614-410-4400 • Fax: 614-410-4490
CIT7 OF DUBLIN_
,~
TO: Members of City Council
FROM: Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager ~' S %~J
DATE: June 12, 2008 ~~ r /-a~wr,~~~,,.J
INITIATED BY: Steve Lanaworthy, Director of Land Use and Long Range Plannino-
Gary P. Gunderman, Planning Manager
RE: Ordinance 31-08 -Pre-Annexation Agreement-BVH Associates
Background
emo
During the May 19, 2008 City Council meeting, additional information was requested regarding
the proposed pre-annexation agreement for the BVH Associates' property at Tuller Road and
Riverside Drive. In response, the following information and the attached sheets have been
provided by Planning and BVH's legal counsel:
The proposed construction has not yet been granted a building permit by the State, but the
submitted plans assume provision of City water and sewer lines. Without City water and
sewer, a new well site would need to be located and approved and a revised sewage
disposal system would need to be designed and approved, all of which would probably be
located closer to Riverside Drive.
• If work is started in accordance with State approved building plans, all building
inspections would be completed by the State.
• The largest portion of the building addition is located on a current open area in the middle
of the existing building. The remaining improvements are related to second story exterior
and interior modification. (see attached material)
• Depending on the eventual zoning classification that Dublin may impose on the site, the
building would not comply with most side andrear yazd setbacks. The average height of
about two stories would comply with most Dublin commercial zoning districts.
• The proposed plans have been approved by Perry Township Zoning. Given that the
additions are all within the current building footprint, no aspect of the development was an
issue in its review.
• The cell tower is located on the BVH property and contains co-location for three cell
phone companies. Two of the three support structures are also on the BVH property near
the base of the tower. The third support structure is also close to the base of the tower but
on adjacent property. (see attached material)
Ordinance 31-08 Pre-Annexation Agreement-BVH Associates
June 12, 2008
Page 2 of 2
The proposed agreement would dedicate approximately 50 feet of additional ROW along
Riverside Drive. (see attached material)
No new signs for the proposed project have been shown, but the sign along Riverside
Drive would be within the new ROW dedication area. There is no reason that new signs
could not conform to City requirements, but this would require Planning and Zoning
Commission review, as this is within the Corridor Development District.
The existing building and parking lots encroach up to the property lines in several
locations and make City landscape code for the perimeter and other normal buffer
requirements impractical. Some interior landscape Vehicular Use Area Requirements may
be partially met if Planning can review the layout of the parking area more closely. The
Vehicular Use Area screening requirement can be met along the west side by the addition
of a wall above grade to the new parking area and the addition of shade trees at the base of
the retaining wall. Other Additional Site Landscape Requirements have been met with
planting around the base of the building, but many of these will need to be replaced after
construction to remain in compliance with Code.
In light of Council's discussion and this additional information, the Law Director's office
made three revisions to the pre-annexation agreement. The first revision requires that the site
come into compliance with the Dublin Landscaping Code, to the extent possible and to the
satisfaction of Plannin6 Staff. The second revision requires that all signs on the site come into
compliance with the Dublin Code, which requires Planning and Zoning Commission approval.
Finally, the third revision requires the two lots that are the subject of the annexation to be
combined into one.
Recommendation
Recognizing the value into the future from bringing this property in the city limits and thereby
allowing the City's zoning regulations to be applied to future improvements, Planning
recommends Council approval of Ordinance 31-08.
Attachments
Annotated Air Photo
Annotated Site Map
Annotated Building Elevations
Original Building Elevations
Site Photos
~.2Z 0
1-270 ROW
Thomas Family, LP
Cell tower support
buildings
Existing Building Unchanged
Existing cell tower
_-
_ _ ~
- -
'' k _~ q
L -
° ~ ~
'~ ~50 feet ! !~ New
'+ Addition
?~
~ ~ / %j
~I~
/ !I
Tuller Road -
____ Expanded 2nd Story
-----------------
Legend ---- -- --------- --- ----~ ------
~~ New Parking ----------------_
® Existing Parking
Existing Sign
~ Proposed Right-of-Way Tuller Henderson, LLC
Existing cell tower
® City of Dublin corporation limit 0 25 50 100
Feet
PROPOSED NORTH AND SOUTH ELEVATIONS
Red -new construction
RDG"~
rhr
'16 Ptf FTl
NUY. R:S
r_- rc 5'G0.7
:w.~ rYP
L....1
E NORTH ELEVATION
Red - neuv construction
Blue -replacement of existing wall with stone finish
+ ,,:?:bCY~ CWL
~
,
S~t+l54A:T 5h.~YtES l~ ~ +v~~ ~ ~ 1~ f!'Yl
~
TN '-lit O/FX tSt RfAF:Y' FE:.'S
+n~Q+F?5r.5H~lit~5
JnC rCD 57~Yi -
--~
GAS
e:~Gi•: i::}{°?:i.°ii?i.it
~'
:•
.
c
,,
//
f"_
_-
~~
I ~ i
~
'I i
~
I
I ~.i c ~ .
~ 'i
®
®
®
C
' i
I
7~ FXST
W.SG`AY 'V~
~
1 ~({ ffq ~U~~y
T .
w,u TO'JE ET7E~OED /
I 1 ~~%( "` BY 4'p ()P N/v<~R.'AY
~ SOUTH ELEVATION
L /v'=i7T1:E '- 5
~ ~
PROPOSED EAST AND WEST ELEVATIONS
Red - ne+v construction
Blue -stone exterior added
r q 1 ~ -
Red -new construction
~~ •--, .snH:rs cc:as
Blue -replacement of existing wall ~~ o~4,.Rp,:4R."5
with stone exterior finish '"" "1 ` ~ '"mot "`~~`'
gg ` w. O
I f ~ ~.a~. _nc.._...
x~ivw.
¢n~.u
~n°N. p EAST ElFVATION
~~ L...._ . _11._I ..
~., ..
~ /
~ ;
r
l
~
.~ ~. ~ ~.,
.,,
.,
tiv~e~n_mra.:mu~.en.ec.+:ec
~'i~ m`oua m:
am~usa r.
mrsiurr~
..v..., ,.~} ._ ..o..
~~p, sin rtnq.
i
51R C~~Ln9N%Jn'~inm19:V
GJiiR5lfYr. DH@E AIJMN. CBV.EGLNRI:
cmn vrmr~,we oznv.
~at.c
.o,
,,,~, .zo
~.o, ~.
h
~ ~
»
.
~...~, , ....
ss~~.a:~a
p
~
~ a51
N
~i 4
`^ U
Z d
J U (\
f'_; N
z
Y ff
N {tZ i`
`` 'N'
n 5) U) N
r 's il J.
(_l
~' eJ
c. r.q
~S„
Y,?4
(~„ 7anD
P124.o0
~1`~.
..' ~' __._ '', ADDfi'Y AND RSYODE~t~G ".°.. `
G n O R
R,YERSiDE DR AMMAL CARE CN'ER
m ~ "` "' " "" '; 6924 RIYFR57~ GR. CUBL?i R~10 ,
..:
((J~~ .,
,. IJ'I ~!!~! ~..
\\ .. _..:.aj
~i)
N
l ~~
N
~ 1]
ll~~ ~
~.l " (]
Q ~y
S ~ '(1.\
N 4 (j
~ ~ 'ri
N
CJ ~ N
{- 0) N ~.
p "~i 1
4 N o
s S
%it
;e~
z.
`~ J rani r i ivn~p?@_
.,ninituvnruav
~6 r. a
/~ msl r.l vnnov__
h `\
_~_....
. _...... _.. _. _........
. n,r.>.zo.nn
rw.~.~2 DO!
d-zn on
~~~~ ~~ Ail
West Side
_ _
__ ,~:-
South Side along Tuller Rd.
East Side
North side Cell Tower
West Side Entrance
North side Adjacent Area
REDLINED AMENDED AGREEMENT
PRE-ANNEXATION AGREEMENT
This Pre-Annexation Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into on ,
2008, by and between BVH Associates LLC ("BVH") and the City of Dublin ("Dublin"), an
Ohio municipal corporation, whose principal mailing address is 5200 Emerald Parkway, Dublin,
Ohio 43017 (referred to collectively as "Parties").
RECITALS
WHEREAS, BVH owns certain real property located at 6924 Riverside Drive in Perry
Township (the "Property"), being more fully described in the Franklin County Auditor's
information attached as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein; and
WHEREAS, the Property is located adjacent to and within the present corporate
boundaries of Dublin; and
WHEREAS, BVH desires to annex its Property to Dublin in order to obtain municipal
services to support the Property; and
WHEREAS, Dublin desires to annex the Property.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises and covenants contained
herein, and intending to be legally bound, the Parties hereby agree as follows:
1. Annexation: BVH is subject to the Perry Township and/or State of Ohio Building Codes
and the Perry Township Zoning Code. At the time of execution of this Agreement, BVH is
finalizing the building plans and will gain the necessary building permits and zoning approval
from Perry Township and/or the State of Ohio as soon as is reasonably practical. BVH will
submit an annexation petition, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 709.02, to the Franklin
County Commissioners within seven (7) days of obtaining the necessary building permits and
zoning approval from Perry Township and/or the State of Ohio.
If BVH does not submit an annexation petition by that deadline, BVH agrees that the Dublin
Law Director may act as BVH's appointed agent and file an annexation petition related to the
Property. In that event, BVH will pay all legal costs and fees related to the annexation, including
attorney fees and surveyor fees. Dublin waives its annexation filing fee for the Property as the
annexation of the BVH Property will fill in an unincorporated area that is completely surrounded
by the Dublin corporate limits. Dublin will accept the annexation of the Property.
2. Water and Sewer Services. The Property lies within the Exclusive Dublin Expansion
Area. Upon the filing of the annexation petition, Dublin will provide access to water and sewer
services to the site with BVH paying all costs of connecting to the water and sewer system.
3. Boundary Adiustment: It is Dublin's intent to file a petition for a boundary adjustment
after the acceptance of the Property by City Council, which will result in the Property
conforming to the Washington Township boundaries. Such action will practically result in the
exclusion of the Property from Perry Township's jurisdiction. Pursuant to Ohio Revised Code
Section 709.19, Dublin must make reparations to Perry Township of a percentage of the
;Hi ~o~sos.~ ;
REDLINED AMENDED AGREEMENT
Township taxes that would have been due the Township if annexation had not occurred in the
amounts as follows:
Years 1 through 3 80.0%
Years 4 through 5 67.5%
Years 6 through 7 62.5%
Years 8 through 9 57.5%
Years 10 through 12 42.5%
After year 12 0%
BVH, its successors and assigns, hereby agree to compensate Dublin for all reparations payments
Dublin is required to make to Perry Township. BVH, its successors and assigns, will pay any
invoice presented to them by Dublin for such reparations within thirty (30) days of receipt of said
invoice.
4. Right-of-Way Dedication: Dublin is planning to install a bikepath on the east side of
Riverside Drive between Tuller Road and Emerald Parkway a portion of which will be located
on the Property. In addition, Dublin is in the planning phases for a road improvement project on
Emerald Parkway ("Emerald Parkway Phase 8") which will require BVH to convey right of way
to Dublin. BVH, its successors and assigns agree to dedicate any right-of--way necessary for the
bikepath and any other right-of--way dedication required by Dublin in conjunction with the
Emerald Parkway Phase 8 project at no cost to Dublin, provided the total amount ofright-of--way
taken along the east side of Riverside Drive does not exceed approximately fifty (50) feet.~f--tl~e
,~~„~; ~~. ~~ + ~ ~~ n„~,r, ~-~„ ~ n, 1 ,~ ,~. The
'Tmarc-~~1~()l^~~~ tzic~c iT~-n"rc'r`~=~i~-n-~-c~ucrri~r~,`t`,c',~,
estimated right-of--way dedication is attached as Exhibit B.
5. Cooperative Development for Future Roadwa r}~Projects. The Parties agree to work
jointly with regard to any future roadway development that occurs adjacent to the Property.
6. Landscaping. BVH agrees to bring the Property into compliance with the Dublin
Landscaping Code to the extent possible and to the satisfaction of the Dublin Planning Staff.
7. Si ~s. BVH agrees to bring all current and future signs located on the Property into
compliance with the Dublin Sign Code, subject to Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission
review and approval.
8. Lot Combination. BVH agrees to combine the two lots that are the subject of the
annexation within thirty (30) days after the execution of this agreement.
9. Council Action: The foregoing obligations and commitments by Dublin contained herein
are contingent and shall be effective and enforceable only upon the approval of all necessary
legislation and/or motions by Council and the expiration of all referendum periods applicable
thereto.
10. Successors and Assigns: This Agreement shall run with the land and be binding upon
and inure to the benefit of the respective heirs, personal representatives, successors, transferees,
and assigns of the parties hereto.
REDLINED AMENDED AGREEMENT
11. Amendments: This Agreement may be amended, modified, or changed only by a written
agreement properly executed by Parties.
12. Applicable Law: This Agreement shall be governed by, construed, and interpreted in
accordance with the ordinances and laws of Dublin, the State of Ohio and the United States, in
that order.
13. Waiver. No delay or failure on the part of any party hereto in exercising any right,
power, or privilege under this Agreement or under any other instruments given in connection
with or pursuant to this Agreement shall impair any such right, power, or privilege or be
construed as a waiver of any default or any acquiescence therein. No single or partial exercise of
any such right, power, or privilege shall preclude the further exercise of such right, power, or
privilege, or the exercise of any other right, power or privilege.
14. Severability. If any provision in this Agreement is held by a court of competent
jurisdiction to be invalid, void, or unenforceable to any extent, such provision shall be enforced
to the greatest extent permitted by law and the remainder of this Agreement and the application
of such provision to other persons or circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be
enforced to the greatest extent permitted bylaw.
15. Entire Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding of the parties
hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior negotiations, discussions,
undertakings and agreements between the parties. This Agreement may be amended or modified
only by a writing executed by the duly authorized officers of the parties hereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have set their hand to duplicates hereof, on the day
and year first above written.
BVH ASSOCIATES LLC
By:
Its:
CITY OF DUBLIN
An Ohio Municipal Corporation
By:
Jane S. Brautigam
Its: City Manager
REDLINED AMENDED AGREEMENT
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF SS
Before me a Notary Public personally came on behalf of BVH
Associates, who acknowledged the foregoing Agreement as his voluntary act and deed.
In Witness whereof I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed my seal on this
day of , 2008.
Notary Public
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF SS
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF FRANKLIN: SS
Before me a Notary Public personally came the City of Dublin, an Ohio municipal
corporation, by Jane S. Brautigam, its City Manager, who acknowledged the foregoing
Agreement as her voluntary act and deed on behalf of the City.
In Witness whereof I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed my seal on this
day of , 2008.
Notary Public
4
REDLINED AMENDED AGREEMENT
EXHIBIT A
Franklin County Auditor's Information
REDLINED AMENDED AGREEMENT
EXHIBIT B
Right-of-Way Dedication Information
PRE-ANNEXATION AGREEMENT
This Pre-Annexation Agreement ("Agreement') is entered into on
2008, by and between BVH Associates LLC ("BVH") and the City of Dublin ("Dublin"), an
Ohio municipal corporation, whose principal mailing address is 5200 Emerald Parkway, Dublin.
Ohio 43017 (referred to collectively as "Parties").
RECITALS
WHEREAS, BVH owns certain real property located at 6924 Riverside Drive in Perry
Township (the "Property"), being more fully described in the Franklin County Auditor's
information attached as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein: and
WHEREAS, the Property is located adjacent to and within the present corporate
boundaries of Dublin: and
WHEREAS, BVH desires to annex its Property to Dublin in order to obtain municipal
services to support the Property: and
WHEREAS, Dublin desires to annex the Property.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises and covenants contained
herein, and intending to be legally bound, the Parties hereby agree as follows:
1. Annexation: BVH is subject to the Perry Township and/or State of Ohio Building Codes
and the Perry Township Zoning Code. At the time of execution of this Agreement, BVH is
finalizing the building plans and will gain the necessary building permits and zoning approval
from Perry Township and/or the State of Ohio as soon as is reasonably practical. BVH will
submit an annexation petition, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 709.02, to the Franklin
County Commissioners within seven (7) days of obtaining the necessary building permits and
zoning approval from Perry Township and/or the State of Ohio.
If BVH does not submit an annexation petition by that deadline, BVH agrees that the Dublin
Law Director may act as BVH's appointed agent and file an annexation petition related to the
Property. In that event. BVH will pay all legal costs and fees related to the annexation, including
attorney fees and surveyor fees. Dublin waives its annexation filing fee for the Property as the
annexation of the B VH Property will fill in an unincorporated area that is completely surrounded
by the Dublin corporate limits. Dublin will accept the annexation of the Property.
2. Water and Sewer Services. The Property lies within the Exclusive Dublin Expansion
Area. Upon the filing of the annexation petition, Dublin will provide access to water and sewer
services to the site with BVH paying all costs of connecting to the water and sewer system.
3. Boundary Adiustment: It is Dublin's intent to file a petition for a boundary adjustment
after the acceptance of the Property by City Council, which will result in the Property
conforming to the Washington Township boundaries. Such action will practically result in the
[Iii1tr230b3 ~
exclusion of the Property from Perry Township's jurisdiction. Pursuant to Ohio Revised Code
Section 709.19, Dublin must make reparations to Perry Township of a percentage of the
Township taxes that would have been due the Township if annexation had not occurred in the
amounts as follows:
Years 1 through 3 80.0%
Years 4 through 5 675%
Years 6 through 7 62.S~1o
Years 8 through 9 57.5%
Years 10 through 12 42.5%
After year 12 0%
BVH, its successors and assigns, hereby agree to compensate Dublin for all reparations payments
Dublin is required to make to Perry Township. BVH, its successors and assigns, will pay any
invoice presented to them by Dublin for such reparations within thirty (30) days of receipt of said
invoice.
4. Right-of-Way Dedication: Dublin is planning to install a bikepath on the east side of
Riverside Drive between Taller Road and Emerald Parkway a portion of which will be located
on The Property. In addition. Dublin is in the planning phases for a road improvement project on
Emerald Parkway ("Emerald Parkway Phase 8") which will require BVH to convey right of way
to Dublin. BVH, its successors and assigns agree to dedicate any right-of--way necessary for the
bikepath and any other right-of-way dedication required by Dublin in conjunction with the
Emerald Parkway Phase 8 project at no cost to Dublin, provided the total amount of right-of-way
taken along the east side of Riverside Drive does not exceed approximately fifty (50) feet. The
estimated right-of-way dedication is attached as Exhibit B.
5. Cooperative Development for Future Roadway Projects. The Parties agree to work
jointly with regard to any future roadway development that occurs adjacent to the Property.
6. Landscapine. BVH agrees to bring the Property into compliance with the Dublin
Landscaping Code to the extent possible and to the satisfaction of the Dublin Planning Staff.
7. Suns. BVH agrees to bring all current and future signs located on the Property into
compliance with the Dublin Sign Code, subject to Dublin Planning and Zoning Commission
review and approval.
8. Lot Combination. BVH agrees to combine the two lots that are the subject of the
annexation within thirty (30) days after the execution of this agreement.
9. Council Action: The foregoing obligations and commitments by Dublin contained herein
are contingent and shall be effective and enforceable only upon the approval of all necessary
legislation and/or motions by Council and the expiration of all referendum periods applicable
thereto.
~xi im_~os.~ 4 2
10. Successors and Assiens: This Agreement shall run with the land and be binding upon
and inure to the benefit of the respective heirs, personal representatives, successors, transferees,
and assigns of the parties hereto.
11. Amendments: This Agreement may be amended, modified, or changed only by a written
agreement properly executed by Parties.
12. Applicable Law: This Agreement shall be governed by, construed, and interpreted in
accordance with the ordinances and laws of Dublin, the State of Ohio and the United States, in
that order.
13. Waiver. No delay or failure on the part of any party hereto in exercising any right,
power, or privilege under this Agreement or under any other instruments given in connection
with or pursuant to this Agreement shall impair any such right, power, or privilege or be
construed as a waiver of any default or any acquiescence therein. No single or partial exercise of
any such right, power, or privilege shall preclude the further exercise of such right, power, or
privilege, or the exercise of any other right, power or privilege.
14. Severability. If any provision in this Agreement is held by a court of competent
jurisdiction to be invalid, void, or unenforceable to any extent, such provision shall be enforced
to the greatest extent permitted by law and the remainder of this Agreement and the application
of such provision to other persons or circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be
enforced to the greatest extent permitted by law.
I5. Entire Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding of the parties
hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior negotiations, discussions.
undertakings and agreements between the parties. This Agreement may be amended or modified
only by a writing executed by the duly authorized officers of the parties hereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have set their hand to duplicates hereof, on the day
and year first above written.
BVH ASSOCIATES LLC
By:
Its:
CITY OF DUBLIN
An Ohio Municipal Corporation
By:
~~~ ~ozsoss ~ 3
Jane S. Brautigam
Its: City Manager
{rmazaos.: ~ 4
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF SS
Before me a Notary Public personally came on behalf of BVH
Associates, who acknowledged the foregoing Agreement as his voluntary act and deed.
In Witness whereof I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed my seal on this
day of , 2008.
Notary Public
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF SS
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF FRANKLIN: SS
Before me a Notary Public personally came the City of Dublin, an Ohio municipal
corporation, by Jane S. Brautigam, its City Manager, who acknowledged the foregoing
Agreement as her voluntary act and deed on behalf of the City.
In Witness whereof I have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed my seal on this
day of , 2008.
Notary Public
,~~uiozsos._ 7 ~
EXHIBIT A
Franklin County Auditor's Information
Hnmsns s 1
EXHIBIT B
Right-of-Way Dedication Information
fNUOr.•oss 1 7
C[TY qF DI~BLIS
Office of the City Manager
5200 Emerald Parkway, Dublin, Ohio 43017
Phone:614-410-4400
To: Members of Dublin City Council
From: Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager
Date: May 29, 2008
Re: Ordinance 31-08 - BVH Associates Pre-Annexation Agreement
Memo
Staff is recommending Council approve a motion on June 2 to postpone Ordinance 31-08 until the June 16
Council meeting in order to allow the applicant's representative additional time to respond to issues raised at the
first reading.
SCHOTTENSTEIN
ZOX&DUNN~~.":,
MEMORANDUM
TO: Dublin City Council
Jane S. Brautigam, City Manager
FROM: Stephen J. Smith, Law Director
Jennifer D. Readler, Assistant Law Director
DATE: May 15, 2008
RE: Ordinance 31-08 -Pre-Annexation Agreement with BVH Associates
(The Vet Hospital)
BACKGROUND:
This office was asked to coordinate a possible preannexation agreement with BVH Associates
("BVH") governing the terms of its annexation to Dublin. As you know, BVH is located at the
corner of Riverside Drive and Tuller Road in Perry Township and is surrounded by properties
within the Dublin corporate limits. BVH desires to obtain water and sewer services from Dublin.
The key terms of the agreement are as follows.
TERMS OF THE AGREEMENT:
1. Annexation: The City will accept the annexation.
2. Boundary Adjustment: The petition will be filed as a Majority Owner annexation, so
the City, if desired, may change the underlying township designation from Perry to
Washington for purposes of providing Washington Township fire and EMS services. The
City will file a petition for a boundary adjustment which will result in the BVH Property
conforming to the Washington Township boundaries. As such, the City will make
reparation payments to Perry Township of a percentage of the Township taxes that would
have been due to the Township if the annexation had not taken place. In turn, BVH will
reimburse the City for all reparation payments made to the Township.
3. Water and Sewer: In our discussions, BVH has asked if they may receive water and
sewer permits prior to annexing, i.e. at the time of filing the annexation petition rather
than waiting for the annexation to be completed In light of the concessions made by
BVH with regard to right-of--way and bikepath dedications (discussed below), we have
made provision for that in the preannexation agreement.
4. Remodeling Plans: BVH has commenced a remodeling project on its property. They
are seeking State of Ohio building permit approval. Since they are initiating the review
with the State of Ohio (and Perry Township), they will remain the agencies with
Memo re Ordinance 31-08 -Pre-Annexation Agreement BVH
May 15, 2008
Page Two
jurisdiction over the building plans, although BVH has provided us with the remodeling
plans to inform us of the scope of the work that is planned.
5. Fee Waiver. BVH has requested that all Dublin annexation fees be waived, which we
have incorporated. Typically, waivers have been granted in cases involving islands.
6. Rights-of--Way and Easements. As you know, Dublin is embarking on the Emerald
Phase 8 roadway improvements and new bikepath installations that will affect the BVH
property. In the preannexation agreement, BVH is required to dedicate approximately 50
feet ofright-of--way at no charge to Dublin.
7. Council Action: All of the obligations and commitments in the Agreement are subject to
Council approval.
RECOMMENDATION:
The Law Department recommends passage of Ordinance 31-08 at the second reading/public
hearing on June 2, 2008.
~HI2106?4.8 ;2
y EXHIBIT
s
PRE-ANNEXATION AGREEMENT
This Pre-Annexation Agreement ("AgreemenT') is entered into on
2008, by and between BVH Associates [.LC ("BVH") and the City of Dublin ("Dublin"), an
Ohio municipal corporation, whose principal mailing address is 5200 Emerald Parkway, Dublin,
Ohio 43017 (referred to collectively as "Parties").
RECITALS
WHEREAS. BVH owns certain real property located at 6924 Riverside Drive in Perry
Township (the "Property"). being more fully described in the Franklin County Auditor s
information attached as Exhibit' :A" and incorporated herein; and
WHEREAS, the Property is located adjacent to and wi8rin the present corporate
boundaries of Dublin; and
WHEREAS, BVH desires to annex its Property to Dublin in order to obtain municipal
services to support the Property and
WHEREAS, Dublin desires to anncs the Property.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises and covenants contained
herein, and intending to be legally bound. the Parties hereby agree as lollows:
1. .Annexation: BVH is subject to the Pcny Township and!or State of Ohio Building Codes
and the Perry Township Zoning Codc. At the time of execution of this Agreement, BVH is
finalizing the building plans and will gain the necessary building pernti[s and zoning approval
from Pcny Township and/or the State of Ohio as soon as is reasonably practical. BVH will
submit an annexation petition, pursuant to Ohio Revised Code Section 709.0?, to the Franklin
Cowrty Conunissioners within seven (7) days of obtaining the necessary building pcrnrits and
zoning approval from Perry Township and/or the State of Ohio.
If BVH does not submit an annexation petition by that deadline, BVH agrees that the Dublin
Law Director may act as BVH~s appointed went and file an annexation petition related to the
Property. In that event, BVH will pay all legal costs and fees related to the annexation, including
attorney fees and surveyor fees. Dublin waives its annexation filing fee for the Property as the
annexation of the BVH Property will fill in an unincorporated area that is completely surrounded
by the Dublin corporate limits. Dublin will accept the annexation of the Property.
2. Water and Sewer Services. The Property lies within the Exclusive Dublin Expansion
Area. Upon the filing of the annexation petition, Dublin will provide access to water and sewer
services to the site with BVH paying all costs of connecting to the water and sewer system.
3. Boundary Adiushnent: It is Dublin~s intent to file a petition for a boundary adjustment
after the acceptance of the Property by City Council, which will result in the Property
conforming to the Washington Township boundaries. Such action will practically result in the
exclusion of the Property ftom Perry Township's jurisdiction. Pursuant to Ohio Revised Code
Section 709.(9, Dublin must make reparations to Perry Township of a percentage of the
Township taxes that would have been due the Township if annexation had not occurred in the
amomrts as follows:
Years 1 through 3
Years 4 through 5
Years 6 through 7
Years 8 through 9
Years 10 through 12
After year 12
8QU%
67.5°jo
6?.~°.~o
~7.~%
42S%
a°i°
BVH, its successors and assigns, hereby agree to compensate Dublin for all reparations payments
Dublin is required to make to Perry Township. BVII, its successors and assigns, will pay any
invoice presented to them by Dublin for such reparations within thirty (30) days of receipt of said
invoice.
4. Ri;ht-of-Wav Dedication: Dublin is planning to insta}1 a bikepath on the east side of
Riverside Drive between Taller Road and Emerald Parkway a portion of w-hick will be located
on the Property. In addition, Dublin is in the planning phases for a road improvement project on
Emerald Parkway ("Emerald Parkway Phase 8") which will require BVH [o convey right of way
to Dublin. BVH, its successors and assigns agree to dedicate any right-of-vvay necessary for the
bikepath and any other right-of=vaay dedication required by Dublin in conjunction with the
Emerald Parkway Phase 8 project at no cost to Dublin, provided the total amount of right-of=way
taken aloe; the east side of Riverside Drive flocs not exceed approximately fifty (50) feet. If the
dedication necessitates moving tfte site sign. Dublin shall move it at Dublin~s expense. l~he
estimated right-of-way dedication is attached as Exhibit B.
5. Coooerative Development for Future Roadway Protects. The Parties agree to w-ork
jointly with regard to airy future roadway development that occurs adjacent to the Property.
G. Council Action: The foregoing obligations and commitments by Dublin contained herein
are contingent and shall be effective and enforceable only upon the approval of all necessary
legislation and/or motions by Council and the expiration of all referendum periods applicable
thereto.
7. Successors and Assigns: This Agreement shall run with the land and be binding upon
and inure to the benefit of the respective heirs, personal representatives, successors, transferees,
and assigns of the parties hereto.
8. Amendments: This Agreement tnay be amended, modified, or changed only by a written
agreement properly executed by Parties.
9. Applicable Law: This Agreement shall be governed by, construed, and interpreted in
accordance with the ordinances and laws of Dublin, the State of Ohio and the United States, in
that order.
10. Waiver. No delay or failure on the part of any party hereto in exercising any right,
power, or privilege under this Agreement or under any other instruments given in connection
with or pursuant to this Agreement shall impair any such right, power, or privilege or be
construed as a waiver of any defau3t or any acquiescence therein. No single or partial exercise of
any such right, power, or privilege shall produdc the further exercise of such right, power, or
privilege, or the exercise of any other right, power or privilege.
l 1. SeverabilitY. If any provision in this Agreement is held by a court of competent
jurisdiction to be invalid, void, or uncnforccablc to any extent, such provision shall he enforced
to the greatest extent pernitted by law and the remainder of this Agreement and the application
of such provision to other persons or circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be
enforced to [he greatest extent permitted by law.
12. Entire Aarecmcnt. This Agreement constitutes the entire understanding of the parties
hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior negotiations, discussions,
undertakings and agreements between the parties. This Agreement may be amended or modified
only by a writing executed by the duly authorised officers of the parties hereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undcrsignal have set their hand to duplicates hereof; on the day
and year first above written.
BVH ASSOCIATES I,LC
6y:
Its:
CITY OF DUBLIN
An Ohio Municipal Corporation
By:
Jane S. Brautigam
Its: City Manager
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY OF SS
Before me a Notary Public personally came on behalf of BVH
Associates, who acknowledged the foregoing Agreement as his voluntary act and deed.
[n Witness whereof 3 have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed my seal on this
day of , 200&.
Notary Public
STATE OF OH 10
COUNTY OF SS
STATE OF OHIO
COUNTY' OF FRANKLIN: SS
Before me a Notary Public personally dune the City of Dublin, an Ohio municipal
corporation, by lane S. Brautigam, its City U~anagcr, who acknowledged the foregoing
Agreement as her voluntary act and deed on behalf of the City.
In ~~~ fitness whereof [have hereunto subscribed my name and affixed my seal on this
day of , X008.
Notarv Public
4
EYHIBIT A
Franklin Countv Auditor's information
Site Prov
9overnrc
Sc't7: +~: c•x
Sir .-. .~. _.. _,5
Summary
~ ~ ~ ~ __,~, .n n.:ir_ ~~;
, ~ , - - .i
Parcel ID Address Index Order Card
212-001246-00 6924 RIVERSIDE DR Street Address 1 of 1
Owner Information
Call 614-462-4663 if incorrect
BVH ASSOCIATES LLC
Value Information
Market Land Value 60,700
Agricultural Value 0
Market Impr. Value 0
Market Total Value 60,700
Tax Bill Mailing Information
Mail Changes Only -Click Here
BVH ASSOCIATES LLC
4590 INDIANOLA AVE
COLUMBUS OH 43214
Legal Description
RIVERSIDE DRIVE
R19 T2 1/4T2
0.817 ACRE
212-0071D -024-01
Sales Data
Sale Amount 50
Date 10;08; 7.997
Deed Type QC
# of Parcels ?_
Conveyance #
Exempt # 908894-D1
Tax Dist 212 PERRY TVJP-DUBLIN C.S.D.
School Dist 2513 DUBLIN CSD
Land Use (400) COMMERCIAL VACA~JT LAND
Neighborhood 00103
2007 Annual Taxes 51.814.18
Building Data
Year Built
Board of Revision No
Homestead No
2.5% Reduction No
Assessments No
CDQ Year
2007 Total Taxes Paid 5907.09
Prin(j Rack to List (« First < I'rcvioas Nest> Last»
Uaua r;pda[ed a~ US/13/2G03
Site Prov
governrr
Summary
Parcel ID Address
212-000494-00 6924 RIVERSIDE DR
_~' , , , i -, _ i - .. _._ ..
Index Order Card
Street Address 1 of 1
Owner Information
Call 614-462-4663 if incorrect
BVH ASSOCIATES LLC
Value Information
Market Land Value 139,300
Agricultural Value 0
Market Impr. Value 320,700
MarketTOtal Value 460,000
Sales Data
Sale Amount 50
Date iC/03i7997
Deed Type QC
# of Parcels 2
Conveyance #
Exempt # 908894-M
Tax Dist 2?.2 PERRY TbYP-DUBLIN C.S.D.
School Dist 2513 DUBLIN CSD
Land Use (479J DOG(CA"r KENNELS
Neighborhood 00103
2007 Annual Taxes 513,745.98
Tax Bill Mailing Information
Mail Changes Onty -Click Here
BVH ASSOCIATES LLC
4590 INDIANOLA AVE
COLUMBUS OH 43214
Legal Description
6924 RIVERSICE DRIVE
R19 T2 1/4T2
0.638 ACRE
212-0071D -024-00
Building Data
Year BuiIY 1951
Board of Revision No
Homestead No
2.5°!o Reduction No
Assessments No
CDQ Year
2007 Total Taxes Paid 56,372.99
Print ~ I3ac1: to List j « Firsl < Pres~ious Nc<t > Lrs[ »
Cn.`a updaM_d on DS113i200S
EXHIBIT B
Right-of-Wav Dedication [nfomtation
Pracl nrl
va Ft'ft BVN q:XtClATfs LLC LWD
nr li:c .,. r+.~
DESCREP'1'IOK OF 0.370:\CRE
RIGEET-OF-R',4Y FOR
THF: ('1'fY OP DIIRi.I
Situate) in the County of Franklin, Slate of Ohix and being in the Counship n(Pcrry, in Vuatter
'T'ow'nship 2, Township 2 Nonh, Range I9 l\'cst. Unite) Stars \tihlary f.anda, anJ brine in the
LOOD aae pan oC v 1 4?0 acre tract of land mncevtd to RVII :\ssociates LL(', us reconieJ and
descrihttl in Inslmment 10971011FI111 )699, n(the Franklin i'nunty Rcenni<r's Office
Bccimm~e, for rcfcrenm, at x i'[: nail sc[ in RiccrsiJc Drvc at the sxuthwcs: comtt ofsaid 1 000
acre tract of land convicerd to f3VH .4ssodatcs LLC, also beinc a corner to an 1rJiS acre
(Audilori tract of land conveyed to Thomas Family LP. m' r¢oniul u+J dexcrihed in OClicial
Record U; I6F15, and nn the cencetlinc of right of m'ay liv 'I'vaer Rd, :mJ the TXf'F. Po/N!
'thence ~ 9°39'I I" £ a Jist:utce of 131.01 feet alms the hrc hnwcen said LUO:) aae tract of
land cum cyN to RtT! Associates LLC anJ hctJ ol'Thonus Fatmily LI' to a PK rml x1.
T hence S SG°21'19" F: n distance x(700.2? feet Passive t1+c riehl M n'oa of Ria=crsiJr Dri. c at
l+i Ob icct, along the granwrs nosh line of sail i.Ofki our !eau and also being the snuthcdy lino
of suit Ian) of'ihom;vc Family LP m :m inm pm sr[:
Thence 5 9°2346" R' v disWnn: of 110.73 feet auras :h< el:mtors atud L000 verc trul Ix Ilte
north line xf a fi3GJ acr< tract xf land mnct_reJ Io the (llv oC Uuhlm us raconied in Uh, ici:J
Rcmrd 199(I000ii to iron pin set;
'Chuxe \ 86°21'39" R' a drstm:ce of 50.26 feel aiun:; ;hr north line of said !\ J:? arc :r:ct oC
Ion) one: <rcJ to J¢ C'ih' of Dubhn anJ to 4s c.a islu:e ca.; nnht el'++:r: ei Rr. crs~Jc Deice iS.R.
35T and an iron pin set; -
lhenw ti 9'21'16" \i' a tirvcmce xf 10.27 feet along the csivnng caz: neiu xl vay of Rivr:+iJc
Dricc(SR. 1>J) 0.+a PK n:Jl set in the c Yvrrlinc afTuiie: Raul:
l hence V N6°23'39" \\' a Jistancc of 50.73 feet alxng the crnsl:nc u('f ulin' Road to the TRL%F.
'l ite abm'c dew rihcd arcn ronUins 03'0 ::ucs within :he Hank Ou ('name Auduor's iinccl
":mnher ?I?-1101216. xf which U?(IS avcs a within Jie present :nsJ xcaiPlnl .d Rirersidc
Drive.
Grnnor dwnu title by Instrunsnl 1997I0rI5U1 Ilrryy, in the mmrdx el f=rank Ln Cxanp=. Ohio_
Iron pins indlrrtcJ set arc $.:5"sill" rchars aeith cup smogs) "Dodson. GJJ6, 6oracas & Kipli'.
:\ drsdn3 of this Description is atmchcA hereto'vnd male a pan hereof
This duscriplion was prepared by Walter 117x+ Do:L nn. Professional $uneynr \"a 6316, Ohin.
::nJ asas base) upon actual sun'eys of the promises p<rfonueJ in October. `007, thrxugh Ianuarv.
2005, aid u{wn uvadabit public records Bcxnnes used m lids Jescnptiun are OaaeJ on Ohio
Smtc Plane C.uardinmcs, South 7.one. N.4DIOfi3 11956 udjustmem), and :.e litr the
dctcmtinatinn ct angles on!y', with the ccntcr!inc o(Tullcr Road being rick? as NKG?S'J9°`A` as
ShOw'n.
~4ahcr A. Dxdsal, P.S. 6416, Ohio
Rurgcssti \iptc, inc.
..t"
mow' ~ IfYTEIt '.
~' 0. \}
i + i ~~
{
E\ ~:~~ ~~ c,:
r ~")' P
,, RF,E y4
I%XIi':~IT B
IrcN~~,A1=_ I,o_)E a c perry Towrl,htp
Qtr Tevp 2
T 2 N
R 19 W USMI
.tc o:: 1 ,
, ,
, _
u. ../.,_l+r, , riT-
oROH QSFU ~I~ Of -WAY
'~ ., .
i
A6 L )"
)
' c S'. ...~
I n
* ).
..
1
i .~
i l/A fN.. .. .. i. _ ... .. .
,,
" .. .. .. .
,. y
p Pvti ASS) IA . I C -
o7q F FR IpF .R ~ I
L~
n nr n7 cov r; a
.. ..I
v - ( I JI19)] (, X28 IaC b9 ~
~ t I o r rf
y '-0.370 ACRES '..00, M.C. ;
~ ~ I U,. • < r y
L
~
(q ¢o
ac. PFO)
. ti 1 )
f of U I L o f r
.
'
,
2 ~' ~
I .
x a l a: n,
~ ...
'
o l F - ~
P.0.9 0" a I ~, N ( : 1
~ < ~ 71 I U. s
i -
~ _ ._
i ) ~
_3
,r fG
. 10
1
'
_. .. ..
'
:
p
_-
,l ..:...A,1 ',
I 1 CAI ~ Y )
T'J~I. _'? Rupp
_.. o..;` _
j
_.. ..___
_..__
___.._
--,..
._
n .e••. ~ -
I I _ _-__
_.. __-_-.
un. .....
I `) ' _ WxtrG
~ t
.n.it. ~ ~ Y '.. ~C ~I
ly 1!a :1 C 'i~ C IN:' 2.t'4 \i "wi ,f . ' V / 1 -t F'I
;.~. /~ 1 !,fit ~ ,.r.. 6 v ~~~ p P C q ~',;. .. .