HomeMy WebLinkAboutOrdinance 23-23RECORD OF ORDINANCES
Dayton Legal Blank, Inc. Form No. 30043
Ordinance No. Passed 23-23 a0
AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO EXECUTE AND ACCEPT
NECESSARY CONVEYANCE DOCUMENTS AND CONTRACTS TO
ACQUIRE A 0.126-ACRE FEE SIMPLE WARRANTY DEED FOR
RIGHT-OF-WAY, WITHOUT LIMITATION TO EXISTING ACCESS
RIGHTS, AND 0.023-ACRE TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION AND
GRADING EASEMENT FROM HAMIDULLAH CASHMERE AND
IHSAN RODRIGUEZ, FROM THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 6226
RINGS ROAD FOR THE PUBLIC PURPOSE OF CONSTRUCTING A
ROADWAY INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENT WITH SHARED-USE
PATH AND CONSTRUCTING WATER AND SANITARY SEWER
LINE EXTENSIONS, ALL OF WHICH WILL BE OPEN TO THE.
PUBLIC WITHOUT CHARGE
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin (“City”) is preparing to construct the Avery Road and
Rings Road/Cara Road Interim Intersection Improvement Project, 20-019-CIP
(“Project”); and
WHEREAS, the Project requires that the City obtain the following property interests
from the parcel identified as Franklin County Parcel Number 274-000075, owned by
Hamidullah Cashmere and Ihsan Rodriguez (“Grantors”), as described in the attached
Exhibit A and depicted in the attached Exhibit B:
e 60-WD: a 0.126-acre fee simple right-of-way, without limitation to existing
access rights.
e 60-T: a 0.023-acre temporary construction and grading easement; and
WHEREAS, the City and the Grantors participated in good faith discussions and have
come to mutually agreeable terms for the acquisition of the necessary property interest
for the sum of $9,955.00; and
WHEREAS, the City desires to execute necessary conveyance documents and
contracts to complete the transaction between the City and the Grantors.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Dublin,
Delaware, Franklin, and Union Counties, State of Ohio, ]__ of the elected members
concurring that:
Section 1. The City Manager is hereby authorized to execute and accept all
necessary conveyance documents and contracts to acquire the above referenced
property interest from the property located at 6226 Rings Road, identified as Franklin
County Parcel Number 274-000075, from Hamidullah Cashmere and Ihsan Rodriguez
for $9,555.00.
Section 2. Council further hereby authorizes and directs the City Manager, the
Director of Law, the Director of Finance, the Clerk of Council, or other appropriate
officers of the City to take any other actions as may be appropriate to implement this
Ordinance without further legislation being required.
Section 3. = This Ordinance shall take effect in accordance with 4.04(b) of the Dublin
Revised Charter.
Passed this 31% day of July, 2023.
hole
Mayor residing Officer
To: Members of Dublin City Council
From: Megan D. O’Callaghan, P.E., City Manager
Date: June 20, 2023
Initiated By: Robert E. Ranc, Jr., Deputy City Manager
Paul A. Hammersmith, P.E., Director of Engineering/City Engineer
Brian D. Gable, P.E. Deputy Director of Engineering – Design & Construction
Kenneth B. Richardson, P.E., P.S., Senior Civil Engineer
Re: Ordinances 16-23 through 21-23 - Authorizing Appropriations of Right-of-Way
and Easements and Ordinances 22-23 and 23-23 - Authorizing the Execution of
Conveyance Documents for the Avery Road and Rings Road/Cara Road Interim
Intersection Improvement Project, 20-019-CIP
Background
The Avery Road and Rings Road/Cara Road Interim Intersection Improvement Project (Project)
provides for an interim intersection improvement at the intersection of Avery Road and Rings
Road/Cara Road. The Project will construct a roundabout at the intersection, curb and gutter for
Cara Road and Cara Court, water and sanitary sewer line extensions for Rings Road, Cara Road,
and Cara Court and pedestrian facilities for Rings Road, Cara Road, Avery Road and Cara Court. An
exhibit showing an illustration of the Project is attached to this memo for reference. Council
approved this Project as part of the 2023-2027 Capital Improvements Program (CIP).
Traffic at the two-way stop sign controlled intersection of Avery Road and Rings Road/Cara Road is
congested, particularly during the peak hours. This project addresses existing traffic volume
congestion on Avery Road at Rings Road and will improve safety for vehicular traffic and
pedestrians.
The Project’s construction plan preparation and land acquisitions were preceded by the preparation
of construction plans for the Tuttle Crossing Boulevard Extensions and Avery Road Improvements
project, 13-013-CIP (Tuttle Project), which will extend Tuttle Crossing Boulevard from Wilcox Road
to Avery Road, construct a roundabout at the intersection of the Tuttle Crossing Boulevard
extension and Avery Road and widen Avery Road from the constructed roundabout to Rings
Road/Cramer’s Crossing Drive. The land acquisition process commenced with the Tuttle Project in
2018-2019. Some of the properties reached mutually agreeable terms with the City, and the
acquisition of property interests were settled during the Tuttle Project’s acquisitions process.
However, eight (8) parcels needed for the Avery Road and Rings Road/Cara Road Intersection
Project were not settled during the Tuttle Project’s acquisition process and were put on hold when
the Tuttle Project was paused in 2019. The Tuttle Project is currently programmed beyond the
City’s five-year Capital Improvements Program (CIP).
Summary
The City engaged Transystems Real Estate Consulting, Inc. (“Transystems”) as the acquisition
agent for this Project. In that role, Transystems has been the point of contact, in addition to City
staff, with the property owners on the Project. The City has been able to reach agreement to
obtain two (2) of the remaining eight (8) acquisitions necessary for the Project resulting in
Ordinances 22-23 and 23-23 authorizing the execution of the necessary conveyance documents for
Office of the City Manager
5555 Perimeter Drive • Dublin, OH 43017-1090
Phone: 614.410.4400 • Fax: 614.410.4490 Memo
Ordinances 16-23 through 21-23 - Authorizing Appropriations and of Right-of-Way and Easements and
Ordinances 22-23 and 23-23 - Authorizing the Execution of Conveyance Documents for the Avery Road and
Rings Road/Cara Road Interim Intersection Improvement Project, 20-019-CIP
June 20, 2023
Page 2 of 3
the acquisitions. However, the City has not been able to reach agreement in terms of the
compensation for the needed right-of-way and easements with the property owners of the six (6)
remaining acquisitions. The City is hopeful that an amicable agreement can still be reached with
each of the remaining property owners; however, Ordinances 16-23 through 21-23 continue the
appropriation process through eminent domain in the event negotiations are unsuccessful.
Acquisition
A Good Faith Offer Letter, the appraisal report and associated information were provided to seven
(7) property owners in March 2023 and one (1) in April 2023. These property acquisitions consist
of the following property interests from the named property owners listed below and as depicted
in the maps attached hereto:
Property Owner(s) Parcel
Number
Property Interests
and Acreage
Auditor Parcel
ID Number(s)
Appraised
Value
Ordinance 16-23 - Appropriation
CRI Outparcels, LLC, an Ohio limited liability
company, as to an undivided 31% interest,
Tanglewood Park, LLC, an Ohio limited
liability company, as to an undivided 40%
interest, Waterloo Crossing OP, LLC, an Ohio
limited liability company, as to an undivided
8% interest, and CRI Ponderosa, LLC, an
Ohio limited liability company, as to an
undivided 21% interest
(SW Corner of Rings Road and Avery Road)
11-WD
2.683-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights
274-000023 $127,200
Ordinance 17-23 - Appropriation
CRI Outparcels, LLC, an Ohio limited liability
company, as to an undivided 31% interest,
Tanglewood Park, LLC, an Ohio limited
liability company, as to an undivided 40%
interest, Waterloo Crossing OP, LLC, an Ohio
limited liability company, as to an undivided
8% interest, and CRI Ponderosa, LLC, an
Ohio limited liability company, as to an
undivided 21% interest
(SW Corner of Rings Road and Avery Road)
11A-WD
1.139-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights
274-000021 $27,750
Ordinance 21-23 - Appropriation
William Reesman and Alison Valentine
(6166 Rings Road)
(continued on page 3)
61-WD
0.126-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights 274-000074 $13,600
61-SH
0.014-acre perpetual
easement for highway
purposes
Ordinances 16-23 through 21-23 - Authorizing Appropriations and of Right-of-Way and Easements and
Ordinances 22-23 and 23-23 - Authorizing the Execution of Conveyance Documents for the Avery Road and
Rings Road/Cara Road Interim Intersection Improvement Project, 20-019-CIP
June 20, 2023
Page 3 of 3
Recommendation
Staff recommends adoption of Ordinances 16-23 through 23-23 at the second reading/public
hearing on July 31, 2023, as these ordinances will allow the Project to remain on schedule and
proceed to construction.
61-T
0.045-acre temporary
construction and
grading easement
Ordinance 19-23 - Appropriation
Kelly A. Maynard and Joe E. Maynard, Sr.
(5522 Avery Road)
44-WD
0.010-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights
274-000080 $32,200 44-SH
0.087-acre perpetual
easement for highway
purposes
44-T
0.007-acre temporary
construction and
grading easement
Ordinance 20-23 - Appropriation
Ryan Lanning
(6368 Rings Road)
51-WD
0.253-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights 274-000108 $19,750
51-T
0.046-acre temporary
construction and
grading easement
Ordinance 18-23 - Appropriation
CRI Outparcels, LLC, an Ohio limited liability
company, as to an undivided 31% interest,
Tanglewood Park, LLC, an Ohio limited
liability company, as to an undivided 40%
interest, Waterloo Crossing OP, LLC, an Ohio
limited liability company, as to an undivided
8% interest, and CRI Ponderosa, LLC, an
Ohio limited liability company, as to an
undivided 21% interest
(SW Corner of Rings Road and Avery Road)
56-WD
0.171-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights
274-000017 $16,100
Ordinance 23-23 - Acquisition
Hamidullah Cashmere and Ihsan
Rodriguez
(6226 Rings Road)
60-WD
0.126-acre fee simple
right-of-way, without
limitation to existing
access rights 274-000075 $9,955
(Final Cost)
60-T
0.023-acre temporary
construction and
grading easement
Ordinance 22-23 - Acquisition
David John Wise IV
(6109 Cara Road)
32-SH
0.034-acre perpetual
easement for highway
purposes
274-000109 $5,650
(Final Cost)
SCALE IN FEETHORIZONTAL0AVERY ROAD & RINGS ROAD/CARA ROAD - INTERIM INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENT35701406/9/2023SHARED-USE PATH ALIGNMENT ROUNDABOUT DESIGN OPTIONN
AVERY ROAD
RINGS RO
A
D
CARA RO
A
D
PROPOSED SHARED-USE PATH
PATH
SHARED-USE
PROPOSED
PATH
SHARED-USE
PROPOSED
PED BRIDGE
PROPOSED
C A R A C T
B O N A N ZA LA N E
RINGS RO
A
DCRAMER DI
TCH
LOCATION MAP
0
400
200
100
SCALE IN FEET
LEGEND
PARCEL NUMBER
RINGS RD CARA RD
AVERY RDCARA CTRINGS RD
AVERY ROAD AND RINGS ROAD/CARA ROAD
INTERIM INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENT
DATE: 9/26/2022
N#
32
44
61
60
11
5611A
51
31323334353637383940414243444546474849500120 21 22 23 24 25 260123456789101112131415161718
1011LEGEND
DATE: 6/16/2022
11A
WD
56
WD
11A
56
274-000112
274-000113
274-000144
274-000111
274-001523
274-000118
274-000082 274-000088 274-000095
274-000066274-000074274-000075274-000065274-000067274-000064
274-000063274-000062274-000745274-000744274-000108
RINGS RD CARA RD
AVERY RD11
WD
11
010-218949
010-297198
CITY OF DUBLIN
CITY OF COLUMBUS
64.189 ACRES
INST. 202203170042867
COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 21% INTEREST
PONDEROSA, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED LIABILITY
AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 8% INTEREST, AND CRI
OP, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY,
UNDIVIDED 40% INTEREST, WATERLOO CROSSING
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN
INTEREST, TANGLEWOOD PARK, LLC, AN OHIO
LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 31%
CRI OUTPARCELS, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED
PID: 274-000021
6263 RINGS ROAD
0.871 ACRES
INST. 202203030034749
INTEREST
OHIO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 21%
AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 8% INTEREST, AND CRI PONDEROSA, LLC, AN
WATERLOO CROSSING OP, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY,
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED 40% INTEREST,
AN UNDIVIDED 31% INTEREST, TANGLEWOOD PARK, LLC, AN OHIO
CRI OUTPARCELS, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO
PID: 274-000017
22.624 ACRES
INST. 202203170042868
21% INTEREST
LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED
PONDEROSA, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED
UNDIVIDED 8% INTEREST, AND CRI
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN
WATERLOO CROSSING OP, LLC, AN OHIO
TO AN UNDIVIDED 40% INTEREST,
AN OHIO LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY, AS
31% INTEREST, TANGLEWOOD PARK, LLC,
LIABILITY COMPANY, AS TO AN UNDIVIDED
CRI OUTPARCELS, LLC, AN OHIO LIMITED
PID: 274-000023
0.171 AC56-WD
CRI OUTPARCELS, LLC
1.139 AC11A-WD
CRI OUTPARCELS, LLC
2.683 AC11-WD
CRI OUTPARCELS, LLC
RIGHT-OF-WAY
PROPOSED
AVERY ROAD AND RINGS ROAD/CARA ROAD
INTERIM INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENT
LOCATION MAP - PARCEL 11, 11A, AND 56
0
SCALE IN FEET
62.5
125
250 N
48495001234520 21 22 23 24 25 26
14 15 16 17 18
1011121314RINGS RD
INTERIM INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENT
AVERY ROAD AND RINGS ROAD/CARA ROAD
LEGEND
LOCATION MAP - PARCEL 32, 44, 60, AND 61
32
SH
32
SH
44
44
T
44
WD
44
6160
T
60
274-000065274-000067
WD
60
WD
61
SH
61
T
61
6109 CARA ROAD
0.861 ACRES
I.N. 202201060003935
DAVID JOHN WISE, IV
PID: 274-000109
274-000110
274-000095274-000088
274-000112
274-000113
274-000071
274-000072
274-000066
5522 AVERY ROAD
P.B. 43, PG 75
MILLER ESTATES
LOT 3
INST. NO. 201412120165400
JOE E. MAYNARD, SR.
KELLY A. MAYNARD AND
274-000080
274-000090
274-000089274-000081
274-000082
274-000093
CARA RD
6226 RINGS ROAD
1.115 ACRES
202106040098255
INST. NO.
IHSAN RODRIGUEZ
CASHMERE AND
HAMIDULLAH
PID:274-000075
CARA CTAVERY RDRINGS RD
274-000094
274-000023
0
100
50
25
SCALE IN FEET N0.045 AC61-T
0.014 AC61-SH
0.126 AC61-WD
VALENTINE
REESMAN AND
0.023 AC60-T
0.126 AC60-WD
RODRIGUEZ
CASHMERE AND
0.007 AC44-T
0.087 AC44-SH
0.010 AC44-WD
MAYNARD
0.034 AC32-SH
WISE
EASEMENT
CONSTRUCTION
TEMPORARY
PROPOSED
HIGHWAY PURPOSES
EASEMENT FOR
PROPOSED PERPETUAL
RIGHT-OF-WAY
PROPOSED 6166 RINGS ROAD
1.000 ACRES
202304130035145
INST. NO.
VALENTINE
ALISON
REESMAN AND
WILLIAM
PID:274-000074
DATE: 5/30/2023
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
0
100
50
25
SCALE IN FEET
LOCATION MAP - PARCEL 51
LEGEND
WD
51
T
51
274-000745274-000744
274-0001425
6368 RINGS RD.
2.879 AC.
INST. NO. 201412230170042
RYAN LANNING
PID:274-000108
274-000021
RINGS RD
0.046 AC51-T
0.253 AC51-WD
LANNING
EASEMENT
CONSTRUCTION
TEMPORARY
PROPOSED
RIGHT-OF-WAY
PROPOSED
DATE: 9/26/2022
AVERY ROAD AND RINGS ROAD/CARA ROAD
INTERIM INTERSECTION IMPROVEMENT NBONANZA LNPENSWORTHY DRSTOCKTON WAYTAYSIDE CIR