HomeMy WebLinkAboutOrdinance 34-22
To: Members of Dublin City Council
From: Dana L. McDaniel, City Manager
Date: September 6, 2022
Initiated By: Matthew L. Stiffler, Director of Finance
Jaime Hoffman, Deputy Director of Finance
Melody Kennedy, Budget Manager
Meghan Murray, Financial Analyst
Re: Ordinance No. 34-22 – Amending the Annual Appropriations for Fiscal Year
Ending December 31, 2022 (Q3)
Summary
Ordinance No. 34-22 amends the annual appropriations for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2022 to
provide supplemental funding in certain budget accounts for the third quarter of 2022. The following
sections provide descriptions of the appropriations contained within the Ordinance, and the reason for the
request. Details of the budget requests are as follows:
Section 1 requests funding authorization in the General Fund:
Income Tax Refunds
Budget authorization in the amount of $400,000 is requested for income tax refunds. As we know, many
employers allowed a significant number of employees to work from home either completely, or under a
hybrid model during the COVID-19 pandemic. Provisions were made in HB 110, the State Budget Bill,
which simplified paying local taxes for employers in 2021. This allowed employers to pay local taxes to the
“principal place of work” (PPW) city through December 31, 2021 in which the employee reported to prior
to the pandemic. Employees working outside of the PPW city would be eligible for a refund for time spent
working outside of the City. Based on W-2 magnetic data, roughly 70% of employees previously working
in the City of Dublin were non-resident employees. The original 2022 budget for income tax refunds was
$5,210,000. As of August 17, 2022, refunds of $4,688,365 have been paid. There is a budget of
approximately $521,635 remaining for refunds to be disbursed through December 31, 2022. Last year, for
the time period of August 17, 2021 through December 31, 2021 refunds of $1,633,929 were distributed.
One large taxpayer received a one-time refund of $720,000 during that time period. Taking this into
account, the City’s projected refund exposure through December 31, 2022 based on last year’s data (less
the one-time large refund) is approximately $913,930, leaving a deficit in the budget of $392,295. A
supplemental budget increase of $400,000 is therefore requested to cover work-from-home and net profit
refunds. Any un-used budget for tax refunds will lapse at year-end.
Income tax refunds are monitored on a daily basis by the Finance Department, and reported to City
Council on a monthly basis.
Real Estate Tax – Land Bank Parcel
The Finance Department is requesting an additional appropriation for real estate tax in the amount of
$32,000. In 2017, the City was included in a foreclosure lawsuit on a parcel of land in Franklin County
(parcel no. 273-008415). By statute, the City has the right to acquire such property for its land bank. This
is a .28 acre parcel located along Riverside Drive. Part of the parcel extends across Riverside Drive, and
the remainder is passive green space/wooded area along the Scioto River. Because of the location of this
Office of the City Manager
5555 Perimeter Drive • Dublin, OH 43017-1090
Phone: 614.410.4400 • Fax: 614.410.4490 Memo
Ordinance No. 34-22 – Amending the Annual Appropriations for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2022 (Q3)
2 | Page
particular property, and proximity to the River, the City’s Administration took advantage of this opportunity
to acquire it “free of charge” by way of the court
proceeding initiated by Franklin County. At the time,
the City was aware of a real estate tax lien for
delinquent property taxes levied on the property. The
tax lien was required to be paid at a later date upon
completion of the land transfer. These cases are not
completed in a timely manner. The property was finally
transferred to the City of Dublin in March 2022. At that
time, approximately $30,000 in delinquent property
taxes was required to be paid on the property. $32,000
in additional funding for real estate taxes is being requested to cover this unexpected expense as well as
provide a small contingency for additional unexpected expenses through year-end. An application for real
tax exemption will be filed on this parcel when it becomes eligible next year.
Health Services - BOH
Additional funding in the amount of $15,000 is requested for the 2022 contract with the Franklin County
Board of Health (BOH). The BOH provides for public health services and plumbing inspections, and serves
as the public health agency for the City. The 2022 BOH contract was approved in November 2021 for
$471,527 which was approximately $19,245 above the 2021 contract amount. Because the contract was
approved in November, the 2022 Operating Budget had already been prepared and in-process of being
approved by City Council. Although a small increase was provided for the BOH contract, the budget fell
short approximately $15,000. The City’s Finance Department has contacted the BOH to inquire about its
2023 rates for this year’s Operating Budget. The BOH rates will not be established until September 2022.
A contingency amount will be included in the 2023 Operating Budget to hopefully negate this shortfall from
happening in 2023.
Section 2 requests funding transfer authorization in the General fund as a result of the City Manager’s
employment contract as approved in Resolution 41-22. At a special meeting held on August 2, 2022, City
Council unanimously approved a motion initiating contract negotiations with Megan O’Callaghan, the City’s
Deputy City Manager/Chief Finance and Development Officer for the position of Dublin City Manager.
Resolution 41-22 was approved by City Council during its meeting on August 22, 2022 with a negotiated
start date of October 1, 2022. The requested budget transfer moves funding from the Deputy City
Manager/CFDO’s account and Economic Development’s account to the accounts of the City Manager to
cover personnel expenses in accordance with the employment contract. There is no net financial impact to
the General Fund pursuant to this transfer as there are sufficient funds in the accounts (due to vacancies).
Initiating Department: Department of Finance (Sections 1 and 2)
Section 3 requests funding authorization in the Hotel/Motel Tax Fund in the amount of $15,000 for
private security. Security costs for the Independence Day celebration and the Dublin Irish Festival have
significantly increased since 2019. This is attributed to the vendor’s rising staff costs. Additionally, more
security positions were needed during these larger events to ensure safety. Funding originally budgeted for
private security was $27,000, but has since been revised to $40,000. The Police Department is therefore
requesting a budget increase of $13,000 to cover the additional invoices for private security for both
events, plus a contingency of $2,000.
Initiating Department: Department of Safety (Section 3)
Ordinance No. 34-22 – Amending the Annual Appropriations for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2022 (Q3)
3 | Page
Section 4 also requests funding authorization in the Hotel/Motel Tax Fund.
• Funding authorization in the Hotel/Motel Tax Fund in the amount of $265,000 for grants
(remission) to the Dublin Arts Council (DAC) is requested. This request is not due to a subsidy, but
rather the higher than expected collection of Hotel/Motel tax for the calendar year. As of August
23, 2022, 89% of the expected annual Hotel/Motel tax collections have been made which exceeds
the estimated collections for this time of year by more than 14%. As City Council will recall, the
Hotel/Motel Tax collections are allocated to the City’s accounts at a rate of 65% to the Hotel/Motel
Tax Fund, and 35% to the Visit Dublin Ohio (VDO) Fund. The financial impact of this request is
net-neutral due to off-setting revenue.
• Funding authorization in the Hotel/Motel Tax Fund in the amount of $3,705 for grants (remission)
to the Bridge Park NCA is requested. This funding is for the annual remission from the operations
of the Bridge Park AC Marriott and H2 Hotels for the Bridge Park Community Authority (via the
Huntington National Bank) per the City’s development agreement with Crawford Hoying
Development Partners, LLC (Ordinance 44-15). 25% of the net annual lodging tax collected from
the prior year (after remission to the VDO) is disbursed. For 2022, the net remission was
$128,702. The original budget amount was $125,000. The annual grant is used by the Bridge Park
NCA to pay a portion of the operating, maintenance and capital expense costs of the community
facilities.
Section 5 requests budget appropriations of $2,568,330 in funding subsidies received from the second
tranche of the American Rescue Plan (ARP). The first tranche was allocated in the Q1 Supplemental
Appropriations Ordinance 4-22. Using the revenue replacement option available to local governments, the
City will increase appropriations by approximately $2,568,330 in the City’s Local Fiscal Recovery Fund for
the purpose of public safety expenditures. Public Safety expenditures in the Safety Fund for salaries and
benefits will subsequently be reduced via a reduction in appropriations, and the budgeted operating
transfer from the General Fund to the Safety Fund will also be un-appropriated. These actions resulted in
approximately $5,155,000 in additional General Fund balance that is being used for City Council and Staff
priorities per Ordinance 22-22 approved in June. The City is currently working on Memorandums of
Understanding (MOUs) to distribute those funds as approved by City Council.
This section also includes a provision to disburse any additional fund balance in Fund 266 prior to
December 31, 2022. To-date, the City has received $20,506.79 more than anticipated. This is due to
additional ARP funds being allocated to eligible entities from other organizations that returned un-used
funds.
Initiating Department: Department of Finance (Section 5)
Ordinance No. 34-22 – Amending the Annual Appropriations for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2022 (Q3)
4 | Page
Section 6 requests funds in the Capital Improvements Tax Fund for the following Transportation and
Mobility projects:
• $340,000 allocated to the Bright Road Corridor project. The funding requested provides for the
detailed design of the Emerald Parkway at Mount Carmel Main Entrance intersection improvements
planned in 2022. The project addresses the need for heightened traffic control along Emerald
Parkway at the main access for the Mount Carmel Hospital, and is a term of the executed
Infrastructure Agreement with Mount Carmel. This project is being coordinated with the Bright
Road Corridor and Bright Road/Sawmill Road Intersection Improvement projects. Construction is
expected to begin in 2023 and is included in the proposed 2023-2027 Capital Improvements
Program.
• $330,000 allocated for the agreement with ODOT through DriveOhio for the Connected Vehicle
(CV) Roundabout Application Project as approved by City Council in Resolution 71-18. This is a re-
appropriation of funding originally programmed in 2018 but remained un-used. As City Council will
recall, the approved Resolution authorized a pilot deployment of technology to conduct connected
vehicle research.
CVs are vehicles that use any of a number of different communication technologies to “talk” to one
another. A connected vehicle communicates with the driver, other cars on the road, roadside
infrastructure and the “Cloud.” The technology can be used to not only improve vehicle safety, but
also to improve vehicle efficiency and commute times. This is planned as a pilot deployment of the
application and is envisioned to collect data of circulating vehicles in roundabouts to inform
approaching vehicle decision-making. This data will also be integrated with data at adjacent
signalized intersections. The pilot deployment is planned to occur at the State Route 161/Riverside
Drive roundabout. This is an optimal location since it incorporates a multi-lane roundabout within
two signalized corridors. Work is planned to begin on this project before year-end.
Initiating Department: Transportation and Mobility (Section 6)
Section 7 requests funds in the amount of $325,000 in the Thomas/Kohler TIF Fund for the Avery Road
and Rings Road/Cara Road Interim Intersection Improvements. This project was funded in the 2021-2025
CIP, and provides for temporary intersection improvements. The project will construct an interim
roundabout at the intersection to alleviate the congestion and address safety concerns. The project also
includes waterline extension and sanitary sewer extension Areas 8A, and a pedestrian walkway connection
through the intersection. The requested funding partially re-appropriates the budget that lapsed at the end
of 2021. This request reflects the mechanics of re-appropriating the funds again for use in 2022 as
required by the Ohio Revised Code. The funding is now needed to start acquisition of rights-of-way for the
project. The project was initially budgeted at $2.5m. Construction is currently budgeted for 2023 within
the 2023-2027 Capital Improvements Program.
Section 8 requests funds in the amount $375,000 to be advanced from the Water Fund to the Water
Construction Fund, and expended in the Water Construction Fund for use in Water System improvement
projects. This advance is necessary to cover construction costs above the original budget amount for the
Riverside Drive Waterline Extension project, and the Waterline Replacement phase 6 project. Staff has
determined that the bids were higher than expected for the Riverside Drive project due to multiple factors:
overall higher inflation, increased trucking and fuel costs, material cost increases, and ductile iron pipe
shortage.
Ordinance No. 34-22 – Amending the Annual Appropriations for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2022 (Q3)
5 | Page
Project Resolution No. Budget Amount Bid Amount Additional Funding
Riverside Dr. Waterline 32-22 $1,130,000 $1,259,000 approx. $130,000
The waterline replacement (phase 6) project will replace aging smaller diameter 2-inch and 3-inch
waterline with 6-inch water main, and hydrants in various locations in Muirfield. The project was bid on
June 10, 2022 but not moved forward to City Council due to long lead times on materials and significant
increase in supply costs. The project is expected to be re-bid later in 2022 with anticipated construction in
2023. Due to an anticipated increase in the project cost, an additional $245,000 in funding authority is
being requested to fund the project.
Initiating Department: Engineering (Sections 7 and 8)
Sections 9 and 10 requests funding authorization in the Fiduciary Funds. As City Council is aware, these
are funds held for distribution by the City as an agent for another entity for which the City has custodial
responsibility. For this reason, these Funds are considered clearing accounts and do not provide
measurement of operations, and they are not required to be budgeted. However, the City prefers to
monitor the accounts, and to the extent possible, eliminate deficit balances. All payments made from
these accounts within the Fiduciary Funds have revenue to offset the expenses with no net impact to the
City’s financial balance.
• Section 9 requests a $500,000 appropriation for the Visit Dublin Ohio (VDO) Fund, for funding the
convention and visitors bureau through funds disbursed through the Hotel/Motel tax collections holding
account. As with the additional appropriations needed for the DAC in section 4 (above), this request is
not due to a subsidy, but rather the higher than expected collection of Hotel/Motel tax. All things
remaining consistent, the current collections are expected to exceed $1m in 2022.
However, the financial impact of the appropriation request is net-neutral due to off-setting revenue. Any
remaining un-spent appropriations will lapse at year-end.
VDO – Fund 804 Activity
• Section 10 requests $400,000 in funding to cover Bridge Park NCA disbursements. Per the Bridge
Street Development Agreement, the City is required to pay-out the County’s collections of NCA charges
and service payments (contractual obligations) from these TIFs. These are pass-through funds and the
City has received revenue in these funds completely off-setting the requested appropriations.
Initiating Department: Finance (Sections 9 and 10)
Ordinance No. 34-22 – Amending the Annual Appropriations for Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2022 (Q3)
6 | Page
Recommendation
Staff recommends City Council approval of Ordinance 34-22, amending the Annual Appropriations for the
Fiscal Year Ending December 31, 2022, at the second reading and public hearing of the Ordinance on
September 26, 2022.